Originally Posted by marshall84
I have a 7.5 to 8 inch penis on a good day (monstercockland.com - same name). I asked my gf if I was the biggest she's had and she said that her ex boyfriend was bigger. She could never really give me a good answer because she said that it was very close but today she decided that his was bigger. She said that he was a little bit longer but a little bit thinner than mine. I can't see why mine being more girthy wouldn't put me at the number one spot. Do girls think longer means bigger? Is it a visual thing? Is she lying? Its confusing and is also bothering me because I don't like thinking that she has been with a bigger guy.
I've said something similar to this on past threads so I'll keep it brief: Doesn't sound like she is saying it to purposely be lying to you, but since you asked in the first place she might just say he is bigger as a 'keep her man's ego in check' kinda thing.
Personally, I think that if a girl really likes you and you know you have a decently big penis... even if she had an ex that was bigger she will still say you are the biggest. Why? Because it's easy to do and positive, rather than kind of down you by saying that you are big but her ex was bigger.
Also, slightly longer and thinner would not qualify as bigger imo. Maybe if he was longer and thicker, but as it stands he has you on length supposedly and you have him on girth so it evens out since you guys are close in size anyway.