I never saw a foreskin before I met my husband. Seriously, I just thought that every male was circumcized. It was a given that if I got that far with a man that he would be cut.
I was quite surprised when I saw my husband nude for the first time. It didn't creep me out, but it was different. Oh yeah, and the size of it had something to do with the surprise. So not only did he come with a foreskin, but a lot of it!
Strange, though, how it disappears when it's not needed.