Well, after reading about it on the web, and since I have benefits from work, I scheduled a physical exam and went and had my first prostate exam also. And a set of blood tests for pre-cancer screening, cholesterol, the prostate thing test, etc.
I walked into the office as the first patient of the day. There were 3 mildly hot girls working in the office, 2 in their 20's and one who was more like 40. All I could think was "Do they know I'm here to get the doctor's finger shoved up my ass?". The doctor himself was about 40 years old. It was kind of hard to feel like a man with that on my mind, standing in front of 3 women.
First the nurse came in and did the usual stuff. Heart rate, temperature, blood pressure, etc. Then shortly after, here comes the doc. He asked if there was anything unusual going on, and he checked my eyes and ears and nose (?), and put his stethoscope all over my chest and back. Then he had me lay down and he was feeling around on my stomach and having me breathe in & out.
I thought he'd want to check out my balls and cock for some reason as part of the physical, but that never happened. Too bad, I was hoping he'd ask about my half-restored foreskin. Apparently he thought that was all, but I said I wanted to get started on the prostate exams while I had a job with benefits, even though I'm a few years too young to really start worrying about it yet.
He said okay, and come over here, drop the pants, and bend over the exam table. I did all that, and he got the glove and lube ready.
He stuck his finger (I think it was one finger) up my ass, about 2-3 inches. For some reason, I thought it'd have to go in further. I was thinking "Ooohhh yeah, you got your finger up my ass checking my prostate" like some kind of pervert :).
He felt around my prostate for what seemed like 10-15 seconds, and that was pretty much it. Then I got the handful of tissues to wipe the lube out of my ass and that was all. Total pants down time was about a minute.
Somehow, I had hoped it would last longer. But he said it felt normal, and marked my blood test sheet for the PSA prostate test.
I've done more anal probing with my 4-1/2" butt plug than what went on in the doctor's office. It was wild, cool, fun, and interesting, all at the same time. But I couldn't get rid of the feeling that the doctor might have thought I was some kind of ass-happy pervert for wanting the prostate test.
My ass tingled a bit for a while, and after an hour or so I didn't feel it at all anymore.
I went to work for the rest of my shift, and was looking around at some of the other people thinking "hey I had the doctor's finger up my ass this morning!".
I don't think I'll have any problem going back for my next prostate exam sometime!