Gay guy here, masculine, regular guy by all appearances, but I have never been attracted to women except recently (maybe). Basically, I dated a trans guy for a while and had vagina for the first time. Now I can’t get enough, but womens personality and appearance turn me off, especially long hair and makeup.
So the question is, is it just the novelty or is vaginal sex 1000xs better than topping for anal? Why do you straight guys even bother fucking women in the ass?
Only two of the 10 women I've been with had any interest in anal sex, one a long term girlfriend and one a hookup. The rest had no interest in anal at all, which is perfectly fine with me as I looooooove to fuck pussy!
With my girlfriend, we talked about it, and she said she definitely had to be in the mood for it. We only tried it once, and despite lots of lube and lots of patience, I was only able to get about 2 inches inside her before she couldn't take it anymore.
With the hookup, we were talking about sex during sex and afterwards and she mentioned she actually enjoys anal and wouldn't have any issue with my size (& by 6). Unfortunately we both had other plans to get to and life got in the way of hooking up again. Just for the sake of trying it, I would have loved to meet up with her again and have anal sex with a woman who loved it.
Biologically speaking the penis and vagina are designed to work together, which is why it feels so good. Since I only 'topped' once and it wasn't fully successful, I'd say yes, vaginal is 1000 times better than anal!