Well I did see the Curious Case of Benjamin Button and I (we) thought the movie was quite good, much better than expected.... Visually lyrical, an interestingly touching study of people, life, circumstance, love (and time) lost, growing old, and the fleetingness of it all.
Of course I might be biased, considering we, in watching this movie, felt all too connected to the events in which this is set, the backdrop locations being all too familiar (and surprising - how certain images towards the movie's end brought tears to the eyes...)
But that's neither here nor there. The movie (contrary to some earlier impressions suggested above) was not "Forrest Gumpy" in any way (imo). And in spite of the unusual premise, it was an interesting study in humanity and certainly Oscar-worthy.
Dark Knight was the best of the Batman movies and though Ledger's performance was (imo) an Oscar-winning one (because of his quite chilling protrayal of a character so whimsically presented in past renditions), the movie itself did fall short in some areas. That whole blowing up the hospital bit...could have been left on the editing room floor (imo).