A Catcher Catches Me

Aufratboy

Sexy Member
Joined
May 26, 2021
Posts
4
Media
0
Likes
37
Points
23
Location
Auburn (Alabama, United States)
Sexuality
100% Gay, 0% Straight
Gender
Male
Chapter 1

This is a story of complete fiction and names have been changed to protect identities.

I remember the first time I saw Nate. He was an incoming Freshmen on my alma maters baseball team. I happen to be an avid college baseball fan as I played baseball until college so I very much enjoy the sport, with the added bonus of how many hot boys in tight pants there are to look at! I am a season ticket holder and large financial supporter of the team and the instituting of NIL has made that financial support even more important and for those that do support the rewards are even greater “access” to the team.

I remember the first time I saw Nate as a Freshmen. He was a tall, lanky kid at 6’3” (first pic below) and just over 200lbs. His frame was suited to hold a significant more amount of muscle but he still had that high school body where he was lean but muscular. While he was never a bad looking guy, he certainly was not my type when he was a Freshmen besides his amazing happy trail and infectious smile.

He was like many other frosh when they first come to college and start playing baseball in a high level league that is much tougher than high school. While he was a stud in HS as a catcher, he struggled his Freshmen year to get any playing time. This was very difficult for Nate because he was used to being a stud baseball player but he is a catcher and it is not a very easy position to play in the SEC. He finished his Freshmen year with only a few games played under his belt and a batting avg less than 0.200. He was very disappointed in himself that he didn’t get the chance to prove himself

I first met Nate at a pre-season banquet that our booster club hosts just prior to the first game and we have members of the club and players and families sitting together at the tables to foster getting to know each other. Since, I had my eye on Nate from when he was a recruit and I was responsible for the seating chart, I made sure Nate was at my table. We enjoyed the night and I really got to know him and his parents and left the banquet with many more ideas in my head on how the next few years would pan out between Nate and myself. A few weeks after the banquet was the first series and I happen to have seats right at field level on our home team side. Players are always warming up in the foul territory near my seats. I happened to catch Nate’s attention and he came over and chatted me up. Man did he look amazing in his baseball uniform. I knew my plans long term so I wasn’t trying to rush things with him and ever make him uncomfortable so I kept it simply as a fan wanting him to do well. I am in the giving level that I am afforded a one-on-one meeting with the player of my choice. So after his Freshmen year we had met in person no less than a handful of times and I had always made it a point to spend the most time with Nate. Towards the end of the season, he was making a point to find me at the get together's so I knew I was on something but I didn't know what quite yet.

At the end of Nate's season, the team has a party on a local lake to celebrate the season and I always offer to host the team at my lake house where they can use my boats and jet skis. While there are many guys on the team that are very good looking, to me Nate was just special. That beautiful happy trail drove me wild because I always wanted to know what was at the end of it. Sadly, Nate also shaved his chest during his Freshmen year which is a shame given that he has the perfect amount of body hair in my opinion. Again, I couldn't tell him that because I was playing the long game. At that party though, Nate caught me staring at him with his shirt off and he smirked. I tried to play it off because I was worried I would be outed and lose my shot at him. Nonetheless, he never brought it up and so I forgot it happened.

Unfortunately for me, but good for him, Nate went up and played summer ball in the Cape Cod league. While that meant I didn’t get to see him until school started back, he needed the development for his game. He had a great summer on the Cape and came back with a renewed drive to succeed. When he came back to school for the fall semester, our team had hired a new Strength and Conditioning Coach and over the fall, Nate put on about 20 lbs to his lanky frame (2nd pic below). Most of it was muscle but it wasn’t a shredded figure. It was the perfect blend of just good bulk for his frame. Through Fall camp, Nate was wowing the coaches and was on track to becoming the starting catcher for the season. I also host the team at my house for their end of fall camp party. While I didn’t monopolize time with Nate, I certainly spent the most time with him. We got into a long conversation about that he was studying business and what his plans were to go in to Real estate if Baseball didn’t work out long term for him. Luckily, that is exactly my trade so I offered to “mentor” Nate that night as he learned about the business. He had so many questions for me and I answered every one with very long answers so that I could spend as much time as possible with him. I knew that this was going to prove to be at the very least a friendship and I was hoping much more. I had Nate over to my House several times for the rest of the semester as the fall was the time where baseball players take a heavier class load so they can take a lighter one during the season. We again had our pre-season banquet and of course I had Nate back at my table for a 2nd year. It was good to catch up with him and hear how his holiday break went back at hOme. He told his parents how I was involved in Real Estate but he didn’t divulge our many mentoring sessions last semester. I took note of that and played along not wanting to make him nervous. Nate was not taking any real estate related class during the season so besides seeing him at the ballpark here and there, we didn’t have much contact during the season, much to my chagrin. The team did not have a very good season either, they missed the post season for the first time in 5 years. Nate had a great season and was going to head to the Cape for summer ball to continue to improve his play. He caught about 1/2 the games this season and while His defensive skills made leaps, his batting continued to be subpar. I again had the team over to my lake house after the season. I made sure at this one to spend extra time with Nate and tell him that I missed him and our mentoring sessions during the season. I felt it was important to take a small step forward to let him know he was special to me. Surprisingly, he also said he missed our mentoring sessions, which I was so happy to hear. I was still disappointed I wouldn’t see him for a couple of months while he was on the Cape. Due to the team being out the post season, he had a week before he was supposed to leave. Just as I was about to “make a move” and suggest having him over for dinner one night before he left He came up and asked me if he and a couple of other players could stay the long holiday weekend at my lake house. They had a few extra days before having to report to the Cape and wanted some time to relax. I gladly offered even knowing I couldn’t be there with them because it would definitely be awkward and figured I would at least eArn some goodwill that I could cash in later. I told Nate that there were just a couple of rules…no drinking aNd boat driving! Also, no parties…I didn’t are if they had some girls over but I didn't want a bunch of college kids or potentiaLly high school kids getting drunk at my house. Nate assured me that it was only going to be him along with Kasey (Sr, CF), Caleb (Jr, SS), Isaac (Fr, DH/C), Andrew (Fr,LHP). I assured them that as long as They promised to behave I would stock the house with alcohol, food, etc since they were poor college kids.

The holiday weekend came and went and I was with family all weekend so I didn’t have much time to think about what the boys were doing at the lake house. When Tuesday morning came, I got a text from Nate saying they were leaving and had the place all cleaned up. I was off the rest of the week so I decided to head to the lake and check on things along with inevitably fixing something they had broken while staying the weekend. When I got there, the place was immaculately clean and nothing was broken. The boys had burned through ALL of the alcohol I bought for them but if they had a big party they certainly didn’t it show. I made my way through the kitchen and bar to see what needed replenishing and made a list for the store. I was dropping my stuff off in the master and going to strip the sheets to be cleaned when I noticed something catch my eye just sticking out from underneath the bed. It was a piece of white cloth so I bent down and picked it up. To my incredible surprise it was a jock strap! And not only that, it was soaked in crusted cum. I knew I hadn’t left it because I don’t wear them a lot due to being a top however, I love it when a bottom wears an old fashioned, white jock strap while I am fucking them doggy style. I looked inside the jock strap and to my incredible surprise, the words Nate #28 were written in black sharpie on the tag.

IMG_1254.jpeg

IMG_1253.jpeg
 

Aufratboy

Sexy Member
Joined
May 26, 2021
Posts
4
Media
0
Likes
37
Points
23
Location
Auburn (Alabama, United States)
Sexuality
100% Gay, 0% Straight
Gender
Male
Chapter 2

My mind went wild with possibilities and then I remembered that I had installed inconspicuous cameras all through the lake house due to previous maids, caretakers stealing from me. I immediately pulled out my laptop to access the camera feed. It records everything on a rolling 7 day basis so I had to fast forward through a few days. Their weekend started very normally, cooking out, boating, playing video games. That night the drinking started as they were playing beer pong on the patio for hours like typical college kids. They came in and started playing video game drinking games. I started to notice that Nate was getting touchy feely with the guys especially Andrew the Freshmen pitcher. I could also see him checking the others guys out but they didn’t really notice due to them all being drunk. Soon, they all passed out drunk in various locations and nothing happened. I was getting disappointed but kept fast-forwarding. They had much of the same next day as the day before after they woke up late. They started drinking again but they moved on liquor this night and they started earlier than before. Again, Nate was being touchy feely with Andrew and was getting more bold. Before too long, Kasey, Caleb and Isaac passed out in their rooms after being piss drunk leaving Andrew and Nate alone in the den just talking with each other. My cameras don’t have sound so I couldn’t hear what they were saying but Nate was definitely making it clear he was into Andrew and he was not backing away. They were both just sitting on the couch with just gym shorts on and shirtless, all of a sudden Nate reaches over and starts running his hand over Andrew’s pecs and abs. I was shocked that Andrew not only didn’t punch him but he was totally into. Then Nate leaned in and he and Andrew started making out! I was in heaven watching this. After a few minutes, Nate climbed in the lap of Andrew as they continued to make out. My cock was rock hard already because I had a feeling I knew where this was going! They made out for a few minutes then Nate said something to Andrew and they got and headed towards my master bedroom.

I had to switch to a different feed for the bedroom and get to the right time but I finally got there. Nate and Andrew kept making out when they got in the room and I could clearly make out both of their cocks being rock hard through their shorts. What a dream come true for me to be able to witness these 2 amazingly hot baseball players going at it. Andrew was grabbing Nate’s beefy ass the whole time they were making out. After about 10 minutes of making out, Nate stopped and proceeded to get on his knees. He quickly pulled down Andrew’s shorts and was almost hit in the face by Andrew’s massive hard on. It was about 7.5 in long and he had low hanging balls. Nate looked up into Andrew’s eyes for approval to proceed and he nodded giving Nate permission to service his massive cock. Nate started by licking Andrew’s shaft and his balls then he worked his way back up his shaft and started teasing Andrew’s head with his tongue. I could tell that Andrew was in pure ecstasy and was loving every minute of this. I could also clearly see that this was not the first time Nate had sucked a cock because he proceeded to deep throat all 7.5 inches of Andrew along with playing with his balls. Nate sucked Andrew’s cock like his life depended on it and he was in heaven as well!. After a few minutes, Nate stopped and looked up into the eyes of Andrew and then said something to him. Nate stood up and walked over to the bed and pulled down his shorts to reveal the very jock strap I found soaked in cum! Andrew was standing behind him a few feet away and you could see him get even hard as Nate looked back and then got on the bed on all 4s inviting Andrew to take his hole.

Andrew stepped up behind Nate and knelt down behind and shoved his face into Nate’s furry ass hole. You could see Nate throw his head back in ecstasy as Andrew proceeded to eat his ass and tongue fuck his hole. Andrew was barely coming up for air as he rimmed Nate’s ass like his life depended on it. He also spit on Nate’s hole and used several fingers to get Nate’s ass ready for his huge cock that was about to enter him. Nate couldn’t stand it any longer…he turned around and clearly mouthed to Andrew to “Please fuck me!”

My cock was obviously rock hard as I was watching this unfold on the screen and knowing it had happened in my bedroom. I had literally had dreams (wet ones) about these 2 guys having sex and it was even better than I could imagine. I couldn’t help but pull my cock out and start jacking off. I had to be careful though because I didn’t want to cum before the end of this beautiful scene.

Andrew took Nate’s directive and stood up with his rock hard 7.5in ready to take Nate’s hole. He spit on his hand and used it to lube up his cock and slapped his cock on Nate’s hole teasing him and making Nate beg even more to be fucked. Andrew put his enormous cock head at Nate’s hole and pushed straight in and didn’t hesitate to go all the in to the hilt. You could tell that this wasn’t the first time Nate had been fucked and likely not the first time Andrew had fucked him.

Andrew didn’t waste any time and grabbed the back of Nate’s jock strap as a handle and proceeded to absolutely pound Nate’s ass. Nate was in absolute ecstasy as Andrew destroyed his hole with his massive cock. I only wish I could hear him moan but I know that they were doing so because they were both totally into each other and their connection was organic.

I was on the verge of blowing the most massive load possible without even touching myself but I had to wait because I wanted to blow with Andrew because I knew he was heading towards breeding Nate’s ass with his seed. There was no other possible end result!

Andrew was absolutely pounding Nate’s ass with unrelenting dominance and Nate was in heaven. Suddenly, he stopped and pulled out and you could see Nate’s hole absolutely gaping open from the destruction of Andrew’s cock. Andrew said something to Nate and he proceeded to flip over on his back and threw his leg into the air and pulled them back so Andrew could easily have access to the hole that he now owned. Andrew stepped up and reentered Nate all the way to the hilt again and Nate was just nodding in agreement. Andrew and Nate locked eyes and I could see Nate’s mouth moving, likely moaning in pleasure. Andrew’s pace picked up and then he pounded in one more time and stayed all the way inside Nate with all of his muscles contracting and it was quite obvious that he was breeding Nate!

I couldn’t wait anymore and blew the biggest load I have ever blown all over myself and it was the best orgasm Ive ever had.

When I came down from my orgasm high I looked back at the video feed and was shocked! Nate and Andrew were scrambling in shock as they were clearly talking to someone else off screen! They must have woken up the other guys with their moaning and screaming! Their demeanor soon calmed down and from off screen Kasey, Caleb, and Isaac walked in, in their gym shorts but all 3 clearly had rock had dicks showing in their shorts.

I could tell this was about to get even better!
 

Aufratboy

Sexy Member
Joined
May 26, 2021
Posts
4
Media
0
Likes
37
Points
23
Location
Auburn (Alabama, United States)
Sexuality
100% Gay, 0% Straight
Gender
Male
If you haven't read Chapter 1 and 2 above please do so.

Chapter 3

I could see the panic in both Nate and Andrew’s eyes and I could tell they were stammering with words before they noticed that Kasey, Caleb, Isaac, who were only wearing gym shorts, were rubbing their rock hard cocks through their shorts while all having a devilish grin on their face. Finally, I could tell Nate and Andrew were not scared anymore and were realizing that the situation had just gotten immensely better! Kasey pointed at Nate and motioned him back to the bed and Nate quickly obliged as he jumped up on the bed, got on all 4s with his freshly fucked and bred hole up in the air to be had again by his other teammates. This was now a full on baseball team orgy! Kasey came up behind Nate and pulled off his jock strap and threw it down on the floor. He started to take off his tented gym shorts and at the same time he directed the freshman Isaac to get on the bed with Nate and take off his shorts. Isaac got on the bed right beside Nate and also got in the same position but you could clearly tell he was more nervous and had little to no experience in having sex with men. It was quite the fitting scene though because Isaac was the heir apparent to the catching position when Nate graduated and got drafted. Kasey is the Captain of the team and he clearly took control of the situation. He is about 6’ tall and about 180 lbs and his cock was a nice 6+ inches but very girthy.

I could tell Nate was giddy with excitement as he knew that his Captain was about to fuck him. I could also sense the fear in Isaac as he didn’t know that Caleb was about to pop his cherry. Kasey and Caleb briefly talked as Caleb was taking off his shorts to reveal another great, cock except his time it was uncut.



Kasey wasted no time at all and stepped up behind Nate’s freshly gaped hole with some of Andrew’s cum leaking out of it. He proceeded to spit on his own cock and slapped his rock hard cock against Nate’s hole, making Nate squirm with excitement of what was to come. Kasey entered Nate with one push and went all the way in, Nate threw his head back in ecstasy. Kasey proceeded to grab Nate’s hips and started to pound Nate’s hole and was showing no mercy. Right next to Nate and Kasey, Caleb was down on his knees with his face now buried into Isaac’s smooth freshman asshole. He was eating ass like he had done it on several occasions so it was quite clear that besides Isaac, these guys were all quite experienced in man on man sex. Isaac was clearly enjoying it though because he too had his head back showing his pleasure. Caleb continued to tongue fuck Isaac’s virgin hole, getting it ready for the onslaught of cock that was to come. Andrew had been watching all of this unfold and was immediately hard again and he knew exactly what he wanted so he stood on the bed and stuck his rock hard cock that had just bred Nate’s hole into his face and Nate didn’t waste a second before he started deep throating Andrew’s massive cock. Andrew grabbed the back of Nate’s head and started to fuck his throat. That made Kasey start to fuck Nate’s hole with even more force. Isaac started staring at Nate sucking Andrew’s cock and got lost in the moment but Andrew noticed it so he wanted to give Isaac the chance to suck his cock as well. He walked over to Isaac and slapped his face with his sloppy, wet cock. He looked down at Isaac who was looking up at him for directions, I could see Andrew talking to him and Isaac proceeded to open his mouth and Andrew stuck the head of his cock in his mouth and Isaac started to suck on it like he was a natural. Kasey never slowed up on his assault on Nate’s hole, he knew Nate could take it and he was loving being dominant just like a Captain of the team should be. I could tell on the video feed that Nate could live like this forever but how I wish I could hear the sounds as well!

I hadn’t even cleaned up from my previous huge orgasm but I couldn’t help but get immediately hard again with the scenes unfolding in front of me. It was better than I had ever even dreamed of in my wildest dreams! I knew I was going to blow another huge load but couldn’t even touch myself because I would blow with just the slightest touch while watching all of this.

Isaac had now started to suck Andrew’s cock all the way down to his bush. Caleb stood up from eating his hole and spit on his cock and then spit in Isaac’s hole as well. He started to finger Isaac’s hole with 1 then 2 and finally 3 fingers getting Isaac’s hole to open up nicely for the thick cock that was to come. Isaac was still enthralled with sucking Andrew’s cock. Finally, Caleb slowly entered Isaac’s virgin hole with just the head. Isaac did something totally unexpected and he pushed back on Caleb’s cock taking it all the way in. Caleb wasted no time to Isaac’s wanting more and started pounding his hole just like Kasey was with Nate’s right next to him. Andrew shoved his cock back in Isaac’s face and he took to sucking it again. Kasey and Nate didn’t even notice what was going on right next to them because they were so connected as Kasey was unrelenting on his pounding of Nate. It wasn’t long before Kasey couldn’t take it anymore and blew a massive load inside Nate mixing it with Andrew’s load deep in Nate’s guts which finally sent him over the edge and he blew his load all over the bed without being touched. Kasey and he collapsed on each other on the bed next to Caleb and Isaac and Andrew all still going at it as well. Andrew couldn’t take it anymore and was ready to blow another load for the evening but he knew he wanted to make sure Isaac knew his place, so he wanted to give him a facial with his load. He pulled his cock out of Isaac’s mouth and finished himself off and shot a huge load all over Isaac’s face. Isaac was a little caught off guard but was into it because he started to lick up what he could and Andrew helped him with the rest by pushing his cum into Isaac’s mouth with his cock. Andrew knelt down and started to make out with Isaac sharing his own fresh cum with the freshman as they made out. This scene in front of him was so hot it was all Caleb could do to hold back his load but he didn’t want to stop fucking Isaac because his tight virgin hole was so tight and warm that he was in heaven. Kasey and Nate were now paying attention after coming down from their post fuck high and could tell Caleb was close. I could see them mouthing “Breed him Caleb, breed him!!” It wasn’t long before Caleb went all the way to the hilt and his ass muscle contracted as he blew the most massive load he had ever blew into Isaac’s guts. Isaac collapsed on the bed, exhausted from the most shocking but enjoyable sex he had ever had but he was still hard and had not cum yet. He started to jerk himself off until he felt a tongue then a mouth on his cock, it was Nate who was knelt down in front of him sucking his cock. It only took seconds and Isaac started screaming, “I’m going to cum!” He blew a huge load and Nate swallowed every drop of Isaac’s sweet freshman jizz. Finally, all the boys were spent and satisfied!

How I was able to hold off from cumming was beyond me but as soon as Nate started sucking Isaac, I couldn’t hold it anymore and blew my second load and was spent. I knew that this video and evidence was going to be of great use to me in the coming weeks and months, I just had to play my cards exactly right.