A "first time" story: size was both good and bad

Discussion in 'Sex With a Large Penis' started by NYC8", Dec 28, 2005.

  1. NYC8"

    NYC8" Member

    Joined:
    Dec 27, 2005
    Messages:
    83
    Albums:
    1
    Likes Received:
    13
    Gender:
    Male
    Sex ed for me as a teenager consisted just about entirely of porn, so I thought (and had never been told otherwise) that average male size was +/- 7". So while I was glad for what I had (while obviously having not as much as lots of guys here) I didn't think it was noteworthy. Believe me, if I had known as of age 11 when I hit 5" that I already had what most men would ever expect to have, it would have changed my entire behavior growing up.

    Anyway. My basic cluelessness lasted right up to the first time. I thought she and I were just friends, so it came as a complete surprise--which was kind of bad news, because I didn't have a rubber with me. No problem, she had her own in the dorm. But when she tried to put it on..... no go. It couldn't even approach the flare, and obviously wouldn't have been able to pass it. The harder we tried, the more it just hurt and the more frustrated and frightened I became. It was then that she starts talking me up, being very *very* flattering and looking for all the world like she was really impressed. At the time I didn't care at all, I was crushed in fact. She could have said I had a 2-foot cock of gold and diamonds, it didn't matter--something was getting in the way. Happily the story didn't end there. She sucked me off several times that night, and stroked me relentlessly before, during, and afterwards, staring at it and still talking me up. I should note that this girl was a total nympho and aggressive dick-fan in general (don't ya just love them?), and looking back I guess I was a little out of the ordinary and kind of a "new toy" for her. She then let me try again soon after some better "accessorization" on my part--another thing I had no idea about at the time--and now with better results, Thank God! :)

    So fastforward some weeks and months. She and I weren't an "item," more like friends with benefits. We had lots of mutual girl friends and would often go out to bars together. Several of the girls start to make a habit of asking to get pictures taken with me, pictures that involve a certain prop: a pint beer glass. Sometimes me holding it, sometimes them, but always in frame, and always with some other girls looking and snickering on as an audience. Like I said, CLUELESS ME, huh, what?

    After literally at least the 5th time this happened, I finally asked one of them, and after much more giggling the story finally comes out: My first-time girl had been relentlessly spreading the story, to apparently everyone we both knew, that I was built like a pint glass top to bottom and side to side. I didn't get any nicknames out of that, but all those joke pictures were kind of a "trademark" for a little while I guess. Needless to say it wasn't even close to being accurate, and since I wasn't her proper boyfriend I still don't know why she did it. She didn't have to "defend my honor" or anything... maybe she thought it would help attract attention and get me laid more. I was so stunned that any girls were discussing my cock at all that I didn't know what to do. They all seemed to have the same basic outlook on sex as the girl I'd been with, so I was hoping if they were interested I could get with them too. On two separate occasions, two different girls asked me if the pint glass thing was true, and between my shyness and horniness all I could say was something like "A gentleman never tells with *words*." I wouldn't lie to them, but I also was hoping for something to come from all this.

    Sadly, I was never able to hook up with anyone else from that crowd. So the legend lived on, a legend I would have been very happy to disprove!
     
  2. Pecker

    Pecker Retired Moderator
    Gold Member

    Joined:
    Mar 5, 2002
    Messages:
    83,922
    Likes Received:
    34
    So. I take it you are no longer a virgin. ;)

    The least they could have done is to fill the glass with beer.
     
  3. Mr.Grande

    Mr.Grande New Member

    Joined:
    Dec 28, 2005
    Messages:
    249
    Albums:
    1
    Likes Received:
    0
    Gender:
    Male
    I can relate to this story. I too did not realize how big I was until my first girlfriend told me. The day after she saw it she told me I had a big dick and how much she loved it. She then said she was afraid she might choke on it or it might hurt her. I guess she handled fear well, because the next chance she got, she pulled it out and put it in her mouth. WOW! I'm sure she told her friends about my size because I started getting a lot of "looks" from them. I didn't hook up with them though, because I was faithful to my girl.
     
  4. rope9839

    Gold Member

    Joined:
    Jun 23, 2004
    Messages:
    1,457
    Albums:
    1
    Likes Received:
    676
    Gender:
    Male
    My first girlfriend had already had sex with two guys before me. I remember clearly the first time she saw me naked, she gasped the standard "oh my god." I asked her if there was anything wrong and she said "No." She also said in kind of a stunned voice that I was about twice as big as Andrew and Rob - the other two guys. I was about the same size as I am now, but weighed 120 instead of 195. The classic skinny hung boy.

    When we first had sex a couple weeks later, she pretty much cried through the whole thing. In fact she cried every one of the 3 or 4 times we did it. She wanted me to keep going, but she said I was so big it hurt. I am sure this was in part because her pussy was still fairly mint and I was doing a lot wrong. But just that same I went from kind of an ego boost of hearing I was big to the downer of having some pretty shitty first few fucks all because of the same slightly oversized cock.
     
  5. longbaugh

    longbaugh New Member

    Joined:
    Jun 8, 2004
    Messages:
    134
    Likes Received:
    0
    But just that same I went from kind of an ego boost of hearing I was big to the downer of having some pretty shitty first few fucks all because of the same slightly oversized cock.

    Man, Its been a loooooooong time , but I do remember that feeling.
     
Draft saved Draft deleted