Okay everyone, I was very encouraged by the thread i started about Obama and the very interesting insights it has offered with regards to how African American's feel about Obama's biracial heritage (and hopefully will continue to offer).
i mentioned to someone in that thread, that there was a topic I would very much like to discuss as it is utterly fascinating...but it will not be touched by the mainstream media because of the racial implications.
For all the controversies on LPSG and differing viewpoints, there seems to be a much more tolerant environment here, one where we seem a bit more able to discuss these issues...
This is an issue that is utterly fascinating, not to mention one that really can no longer be ignored because of all the evidence in front of us...
That being the performance of different races in athletics in terms of natural physical abilities.
How we as whites, blacks, asians, latinos of all continents and regions successes in athletics are primarily determined by each of our unique genetic heritage.
The "rub" of this topic is that the genetic/physical ability, has been used in the past in two negative ways:
1. Many sought to link it with intelligence, i.e. stating that blacks had lower intelligences etc. (the bell-curve controversy)...those idiots, as well as those on the other side who forbid even a scientific rational look at athletics as well as "Racial Scientists" using it to degrade other people's talents or intelligence are not welcome in this discussion. Being Jewish myself and being familiar with the Nazi Eugenecists I am well aware of just how thin the ice is on this topic.
If you seek to try to relate anything about the intelligence of different peoples, don't post it here. You have no place in this discussion. Same goes for those who would forbid discussion as "insensitive" of a fascinating and important topic about who we all are as creatures who have evolved in different places, and how those differences, in weather, climate, biology, necessity give each of our races a different advantage across a variety of athletic disciplines, from sprinting to jumping, to swimming to weightilfting.
2. Even the famous and brilliant african american sociologist HArry Edwards stated this "What really is being said in a kind of underhanded way," comments Harry Edwards of University of California/Berkeley, "is that blacks are closer to beasts and animals in terms of their genetic and physical and anatomical make up than they are to the rest of humanity. And that's where the indignity comes in."
I do not buy this...since we are all beasts and animals, and whites also have genetic traits which make them better at certain sports because of our physical makeup that could say we are closer to beasts and asians as well.
So what do you guys think? Do you think we can do this? Is this subject fascinating to anyone, on a natural/biological level?
If we can discuss things like adults amongst one other and everyone could, would it be easier for us to have larger discussions in society about our races? How do we fix things in other areas of race relations if we cannot talk about things honestly and openly? If blacks cannot tell whites about encountering racism, how are whites supposed to understand? If whites don't tell blacks their fears about the black community how can blacks assuage the white community? How do we move ahead if we cannot even talk, even if it is so hard or touchy?
Hopefully, the AA folks that joined me in the Obama thread, will contribute to this as wonderfully as they did there (along with others) I think, considering what has been said about Obama being someone who can relate to other races and diversity, he would be someone who would be perfectly comfortable saying..."okay guys, let's talk about this topic"...I saw a video of Obama on REAL SPORTS (I think that was it) where he discussed how much basketball meant to him in his life and playing it and how it helped his friendships...I think if he was just sitting around here on LPSG, it would be a topic he'd have the guts to say "let's take this on...let's talk about this...not as a racial issue...but a fascinating topic...maybe something will come of it"
Below is a link to a two part short excerpt article, written by Jon Entine, from his 2001 book
Taboo: Why Black Athletes Dominate Sport and Why We are Frightened to Talk About it
To decide if this is "okay" to talk about, I posted a brief snippet that I watched on Jesse Jackson's old show on CNN "Both Sides", where he interviewed Bryan Burwell, and Jon Entine, and this was the last part of their exchange that i found very encouraging.
JACKSON: So you think it (the book) contributes to racism in some way.
Bryan, do you think this contributes to racism or just the race dialogue?
BURWELL: I think it does a little of both. I don't question John's intentions, but I do think that this will provide fuel for those who want to walk on either side of the road.
I enjoy the fact that it has opened up a dialogue and allows us to knock down some of these idiotic theories. But the reality is that no matter what we say, those who want to believe in the genetic superiority and the intellectual inferiority are going to take this and run with it and say, See, I told you.
JACKSON: But, John, isn't that victory for you that what Bryan is saying, that he welcomes a dialogue and the debate and it's no longer taboo? Is that not your point?
ENTINE: Well that was my goal in this was, in fact, the reason that there has been a taboo on this issue is because people harbor racist notions. They're afraid to talk about it because it almost legitimizes the racist notion that blacks are intellectually inferior. History suggests that that's not accurate, that's not part of African- American sports history and it's definitely not part of science.
I hope some of you are interested to read the excerpt and maybe we could have a good discussion about it. :smile:
This snippet has an interestinng bit about Arthur Ashe (the book in its entirety is very interesting and i read it awhile ago)
The Story Behind the Amazing Success of Black Athletes,
Part 1
The Story Behind the Amazing Success of Black Athletes, by Jon Entine
Part 2
The Story Behind the Amazing Success of Black Athletes, by Jon Entine
and this fantastic article written by him for Blackathlete.net is updated and from 2006 and extremely interesting as well
Why Black Athletes Dominate Sports and Why We're Afraid To Talk About It
I look forward to your opinions :smile:
i mentioned to someone in that thread, that there was a topic I would very much like to discuss as it is utterly fascinating...but it will not be touched by the mainstream media because of the racial implications.
For all the controversies on LPSG and differing viewpoints, there seems to be a much more tolerant environment here, one where we seem a bit more able to discuss these issues...
This is an issue that is utterly fascinating, not to mention one that really can no longer be ignored because of all the evidence in front of us...
That being the performance of different races in athletics in terms of natural physical abilities.
How we as whites, blacks, asians, latinos of all continents and regions successes in athletics are primarily determined by each of our unique genetic heritage.
The "rub" of this topic is that the genetic/physical ability, has been used in the past in two negative ways:
1. Many sought to link it with intelligence, i.e. stating that blacks had lower intelligences etc. (the bell-curve controversy)...those idiots, as well as those on the other side who forbid even a scientific rational look at athletics as well as "Racial Scientists" using it to degrade other people's talents or intelligence are not welcome in this discussion. Being Jewish myself and being familiar with the Nazi Eugenecists I am well aware of just how thin the ice is on this topic.
If you seek to try to relate anything about the intelligence of different peoples, don't post it here. You have no place in this discussion. Same goes for those who would forbid discussion as "insensitive" of a fascinating and important topic about who we all are as creatures who have evolved in different places, and how those differences, in weather, climate, biology, necessity give each of our races a different advantage across a variety of athletic disciplines, from sprinting to jumping, to swimming to weightilfting.
2. Even the famous and brilliant african american sociologist HArry Edwards stated this "What really is being said in a kind of underhanded way," comments Harry Edwards of University of California/Berkeley, "is that blacks are closer to beasts and animals in terms of their genetic and physical and anatomical make up than they are to the rest of humanity. And that's where the indignity comes in."
I do not buy this...since we are all beasts and animals, and whites also have genetic traits which make them better at certain sports because of our physical makeup that could say we are closer to beasts and asians as well.
So what do you guys think? Do you think we can do this? Is this subject fascinating to anyone, on a natural/biological level?
If we can discuss things like adults amongst one other and everyone could, would it be easier for us to have larger discussions in society about our races? How do we fix things in other areas of race relations if we cannot talk about things honestly and openly? If blacks cannot tell whites about encountering racism, how are whites supposed to understand? If whites don't tell blacks their fears about the black community how can blacks assuage the white community? How do we move ahead if we cannot even talk, even if it is so hard or touchy?
Hopefully, the AA folks that joined me in the Obama thread, will contribute to this as wonderfully as they did there (along with others) I think, considering what has been said about Obama being someone who can relate to other races and diversity, he would be someone who would be perfectly comfortable saying..."okay guys, let's talk about this topic"...I saw a video of Obama on REAL SPORTS (I think that was it) where he discussed how much basketball meant to him in his life and playing it and how it helped his friendships...I think if he was just sitting around here on LPSG, it would be a topic he'd have the guts to say "let's take this on...let's talk about this...not as a racial issue...but a fascinating topic...maybe something will come of it"
Below is a link to a two part short excerpt article, written by Jon Entine, from his 2001 book
Taboo: Why Black Athletes Dominate Sport and Why We are Frightened to Talk About it
To decide if this is "okay" to talk about, I posted a brief snippet that I watched on Jesse Jackson's old show on CNN "Both Sides", where he interviewed Bryan Burwell, and Jon Entine, and this was the last part of their exchange that i found very encouraging.
JACKSON: So you think it (the book) contributes to racism in some way.
Bryan, do you think this contributes to racism or just the race dialogue?
BURWELL: I think it does a little of both. I don't question John's intentions, but I do think that this will provide fuel for those who want to walk on either side of the road.
I enjoy the fact that it has opened up a dialogue and allows us to knock down some of these idiotic theories. But the reality is that no matter what we say, those who want to believe in the genetic superiority and the intellectual inferiority are going to take this and run with it and say, See, I told you.
JACKSON: But, John, isn't that victory for you that what Bryan is saying, that he welcomes a dialogue and the debate and it's no longer taboo? Is that not your point?
ENTINE: Well that was my goal in this was, in fact, the reason that there has been a taboo on this issue is because people harbor racist notions. They're afraid to talk about it because it almost legitimizes the racist notion that blacks are intellectually inferior. History suggests that that's not accurate, that's not part of African- American sports history and it's definitely not part of science.
I hope some of you are interested to read the excerpt and maybe we could have a good discussion about it. :smile:
This snippet has an interestinng bit about Arthur Ashe (the book in its entirety is very interesting and i read it awhile ago)
The Story Behind the Amazing Success of Black Athletes,
Part 1
The Story Behind the Amazing Success of Black Athletes, by Jon Entine
Part 2
The Story Behind the Amazing Success of Black Athletes, by Jon Entine
and this fantastic article written by him for Blackathlete.net is updated and from 2006 and extremely interesting as well
Why Black Athletes Dominate Sports and Why We're Afraid To Talk About It
I look forward to your opinions :smile:
Last edited: