He had a long-standing bet at the Friar's Club that his was the biggest. It was public record. George Burns, Jackie Gleason, they used to officiate the contests. Forrest Tucker was the only one who ever came close, the challenger would always whip his out first, and then Uncle Miltie would take out just enough to beat the other guy. They have a sculpture in one of the private rooms at the club made from a plaster cast of his penis. Red Buttons said in an interview it was bigger than what he'd seen in a John Holmes movie. At his funeral in his eulogy Freddie Roman said "On April First and Second, his penis will be buried".