Excellent, excellent choices. Paul Newman was a hottie in his days. Grrr...and yum.
I am going further to the olden days of the silent movie era, but I always thought Ramon Novarro was one of the cutest silent stars of his days. I know, this was the era of the "pancake makeup" where everything was required back then for all stars to wear, but I always thought Ramon was much better looking than Rudolph Valentino. He was just one of the few that had a very angelic and curious appeal to him that was astonishing. True, he didn't make it into the talkie era that well, but he had a very unique appeal that was rare in silent film male stars. With the exception of a very young Douglas Fairbanks, Jr. ages between 18 and 19, I always thought Ramon was the most visual looking silent star of his days.