I know this is the zillionth post on the subject, but why not? The best study I know of is the Lifestyles one which was not self-reported. Average is 4.8". 5.5" is about the 91st percentile. And for the first half inch increase in girth over average a penis gains 22% in volume. This percentage goes up after the first half inch. For each half inch increase in length a penis only gains 8%. This effect stays the same. Yay girth!
http://www.lpsg.org/members/aglets/albums/girth+stats/77968-girth.jpg
http://www.lpsg.org/members/aglets/albums/girth+stats/77968-girth.jpg