I personally believe the U.S. Americans are unable to do so because, uh, some, uh...people out there in our nation don't have maps, and, uh, I believe that our education like such as South Africa and, uh, the Iraq ...:wink:
comic perfection, mem.
...For those of you outside the US, here's a brief synopsis of how American primary and secondary education works. Schools are segregated into ....
I endorse this post as cogent and astute. This nails it.
When I was a teenager (well, it probably started when I was about 12), my mother and I used to sit down and watch the news every night....
I am not one to have a kneejerk reaction to problems with youth by invoking the traditional family, but Meg has an important point here. More than ever, kids are hugely influenced by school, peers, and the media compared to times past. However, the environment they grow up in, be it a family (or a group home for that matter), still has a lot of influence on the mental makeup of a growing child.
Meg's observation is a good example. In homes where certain levels of awareness of the outside world is discussed and valued, the kids will take on those habits and those tendencies. In a family that keeps up with politics and current events and discusses them around the dinner table (or wherever) the kids will grow up and maintain that kind of awareness.
This is the reason why some subculture, even in America, put out children who excell academically. Get invited to supper in a Jewish or an Asian household and pay attention to the dinner conversation. I have a number of Jewish relatives, and I can tell you that the dinner conversation is lively contentious, and articulate, when it comes to politics and other things. The debate is complex, and the level of knowledge of the subject matter is very high.
Especially on the East Coast near New York, where the general demeanor of everyone is "in your face", dear friends and close relatives will have vigorous arguments with each other about politics or something where no punches are pulled. Although it will seem confrontational, there will be a general subtext to the conversation that the importance of the subject matter, the importance of the ideas, and the importance of the debate is what is fueling the passion, and not anything personal.
This kind of stuff goes on whether the adults are white collar, blue collar, college educated or not. In fact, in a big Jewish family event, you will have a very difficult time distinguishing who among them is college educated or not.
Going from my usual white-bread WASP midwest environment to visit my Jewish relatives, the difference is like day and night. You cannot bring up any topic without three of them joining the discussion parsing your argument into little pieces, and then giving them back to you with a different spin.
One of my Jewish relatives is a lawyer and one is a carpet layer, and I can easily lose an argument with either of them on sheer logic alone. Arguing with them about politics, for example, is like wrestling with a tiger and I look forward to those dinner table discussions whenever I make the trip back east.
My point is that this is all cultural. It is passed from generation to generation by example, and by setting a standard that life is to be lived in many ways including intellectually.
This long-winded example is not meant to suggest that we all become Jewish. It is meant to illustrate the power and influence the culture of any particular family has on the development of a child, even in this age where most of the influences are external.