I'm an old member who stops by from time to time. Just to let you guys know, anal is the best, but only if you do it right. I don't know about you, but I don't get off on hurting my lover (man or woman). To get your girl into anal, start slow. Eat her pussy and give it a few licks from time to time. The sensation will drive her wild. Also, have her play with your ass. It feels good and you know what, you'll understand what she will be feeling if you go too fast or don't use enough lube or take your time. I have taken a guy the size around of a soda can (hurt like a motherfucker, but once I got it in, felt like nothing else in the world). And I have turned a number of women into anal sluts. I had one girl who only wanted anal because they gave her the "best orgasms" .
Now, what does it feel like? The texture of the anus is different from that of the vagina. I feel that it's "hotter" both in temperature and excitement. It's not always tighter (in fact, I've had girls with tighter pussies than their asses).
(Bareback anal is the best, but don't do it unless you know your partner is safe, the best sex in the world can't top a life threatening illness)