As a biology student, I'd like to put a few points on the table:
1) Natural selection, many people seem to ignore this part of evolution, it doesn't surprise me that people who do ignore it think evolution is wrong, because the whole thing fails without natural selection.
2) "The theory of Evolution is just a theory" Well, actually, it doesn't work like that. The word "Theory" means something different in scientific launguage than it does in everyday talk. Most people use the word "Theory" to describe an idea that hasn't been proven. However, scientists use the word "Hypothesis" for an idea that hasn't been proven. The word "Theory" in science is used when someone discovers something, but it's not physical, like gravity, it's called "The theory of gravity" you can't hold gravity in your hand, you can hold evolution in your hand, it's a concept, that has been seen to work in nature.
3) souls. Do we have souls? It seems odd. The idea that when we die, then there is a part of us that goes into the afterlife, and sees all or already dead loved one's is quite a difficult idea indeed.
Why? because of brain damage, throughout recent history, we've had excellent medical records made.
Some people, have, sadly, recived massive brain damage, but still survived, only to find that they have almost no memories, and can't recognise their friends and reletives.
So, is a soul really possible? Death involves the complete destruction of the brain though lack of oxygen, so how do we go on to recognise our loved ones on the other side? Surely if there was a soul that kept our thoughts and memories, it would correct any effects of brain damage?