While I agree with this opinion, you then heavily contradict yourself by stating:
So, in my profile I state that I'm 1% straight. Does that mean I should stop lying to myself as well, and come out as bi-curious about heterosexuality? Because that is what you are saying about that guy.
It isn't about how they identify themselves. Nor is it anyone else's place to set rules and definitions on their sexuality. The OP wasn't asking if anyone thought his friend was truly straight or not. He was asking about the relationship itself, and if anyone had similar experiences, or an opinion on if it was "normal".
I did not contradict myself. I said everyone is free to identify their own sexuality, but that does not limit anyone to their own opinion. In my opinion both of these men are lying about their sexuality, and I stated clearly that this is my own opinion, but they are free to define it how they want.
You conveniently left out the part where I specifically said that "I don't think its weird."
I don't think its weird for you two to be doing this, but I think its weird that neither of you are really being honest with yourselves.