rbkwp
Mythical Member
- Joined
- Aug 21, 2007
- Posts
- 80,713
- Media
- 1
- Likes
- 45,982
- Points
- 608
- Location
- Auckland (New Zealand)
- Sexuality
- 100% Gay, 0% Straight
- Gender
- Male
apparently
prefer to call them the LPSG PERFECTIONISTS myself
they are here obviously
we know who they are ..bc site aside,its there lifes ambition huh ..
But Grammarist is correct that "to stop it is probably a lost cause" -- emphasis on the word "probably."
http://nowiknow.com/this-headline-is-comprised-of-at-least-one-mistake/
This Headline is Comprised of at Least One Mistake
If you don't see the mistake in the headline above, don't worry -- you're hardly alone. Highlighting the mistake is pedantic, but, so often is the case with little bits of grammar. But let's do it anyway. The problem is with the use of the words "comprised of" -- it's wrong. Grammarist explains:
Comprise means to consist of or to be composed of. Compose means to make up the constituent parts of. Parts compose the whole, and the whole comprises the parts. For example, we could say that the United States comprises 50 states and that the 50 states compose the United States.
But comprise is widely used in illogical ways, mainly in phrases such as is comprised of. For example, many people would write that the United States is comprised of 50 states even though they obviously mean compose instead of comprise. This usage is so widespread that trying to stop it is probably a lost cause, and we increasingly have to turn to editorially fastidious publications to find comprise used the old way. Still, careful writers tend to avoid the mixup.
In other words, you shouldn't ever use the phrase "comprised of." And there's no need to take Grammarist's word for it -- the OED agrees, calling the construction "incorrect."
prefer to call them the LPSG PERFECTIONISTS myself
they are here obviously
we know who they are ..bc site aside,its there lifes ambition huh ..
But Grammarist is correct that "to stop it is probably a lost cause" -- emphasis on the word "probably."
http://nowiknow.com/this-headline-is-comprised-of-at-least-one-mistake/
This Headline is Comprised of at Least One Mistake
If you don't see the mistake in the headline above, don't worry -- you're hardly alone. Highlighting the mistake is pedantic, but, so often is the case with little bits of grammar. But let's do it anyway. The problem is with the use of the words "comprised of" -- it's wrong. Grammarist explains:
Comprise means to consist of or to be composed of. Compose means to make up the constituent parts of. Parts compose the whole, and the whole comprises the parts. For example, we could say that the United States comprises 50 states and that the 50 states compose the United States.
But comprise is widely used in illogical ways, mainly in phrases such as is comprised of. For example, many people would write that the United States is comprised of 50 states even though they obviously mean compose instead of comprise. This usage is so widespread that trying to stop it is probably a lost cause, and we increasingly have to turn to editorially fastidious publications to find comprise used the old way. Still, careful writers tend to avoid the mixup.
In other words, you shouldn't ever use the phrase "comprised of." And there's no need to take Grammarist's word for it -- the OED agrees, calling the construction "incorrect."