Why would your feelings take a hit? I don't get it. I have slept with virigns and girls that don't have a virgin body part and I much prefer the later.
On first look it seems like it is more embarrassment on your part that you couldn't score, but she could.
Oh and you could be very right about that. I wasn't really busy with scoring in my younger years.
But I also see/saw (confused guy here) sex as something sacred. I was always pushing the open sex environment away from me. Don't wanna get into an entire psychodump here. Maybe I'll make a post about it later, if someone is interested.
Anyway, when I found out she had sex multiple times before me, not just with boyfriends (I could handle that, think its normal) but also had some 1 night stands. And she gave a 23 year old guy a handjob in his car when she was 13.
That was kinda hard for me to swallow. Especially since I was very careful with sex.
I was dumb. Realising my mistake doesn't make it easy though. I try to not get bothered. She understands me too.