Originally posted by jonb@Aug 1 2004, 05:48 PM
Well, it's interesting: Republicans accuse Kerry of flip-flopping -- and anyone who's in Washington for 20 years can't help but flip-flop -- but say Bush is resolute. Yes, Bush is resolute, just like one George Armstrong Custer.
This is the Kool-aid that the Bush-Cheney campaign would have you drink. Their spokespeople have repeated these talking points over and over
and over in press interviews: (Both list items link to George W. Bush's official campaign site.)
- John Kerry is the number 1 most liberal Senator!
- John Kerry is a flip-flopper!
Now, if you buy talking point #1, then it must follow that John Kerry would have to be
very consistent about voting liberal in order to outrank the likes of Ted Kennedy and Barbara Boxer. How, after all, could a fence-sitting flip-flopper be so extreme as to rank as the
number one liberal member of the Senate? So, if you believe talking point #1, you must reject talking point #2.
Conversely, if you buy talking point #2, you must believe that sometimes Kerry votes one way on an issue, and sometimes he votes a different way on that same issue. That is, some of his votes are liberal, and a significant number of similar votes are conservative. Then, you must also believe that John Kerry could not possibly be seen to be as liberal overall as those Democratic members of the Senate who do not flip-flop on their liberal agenda. In other words, if you believe talking point #2, you must reject talking point #1.
It is possible, of course, to reject
both talking points. (You may, for example, believe John Kerry to be a steady, consistent, moderate Senator.)
It is not logically valid, however, to accept both talking points, since they are mutually contradictory.
Now regardless of whether you believe 1 but not 2, or you believe 2 but not 1, or you believe neither talking point, it follows that the Bush campaign is engaging in at least one misleading negative attack against John Kerry.
And that, my friends, supports the Democratic talking point that George W. Bush misleads the public.