Best reaction to your size for the first time (legal age only)

[category8]

One of the more successful and entertaining threads in LPSG history was deleted by the mods apparently because some of the stories seemed to involve minors. We should all know that anything that even smacks of a reference to minors in the forums will not fly.

With that in mind, let's bring this thread back, and keep it back, by abiding by that simple rule.

For those not familiar with this thread in the first place, the title pretty much says it all. What good comments and reactions have you gotten?

 

[category8]

Of course, I started this thread because I have a contribution ready to go. From last night (she is my age):

"You're very thick. It's very nice."

 

[hungrockhunk]

During recent sex I told the girl, "Your body is amazing." And she just responded back with a big moan of "Your dick is amazing!"

 

[matute814]

One time I did sex with two women, once is a friend of mine and the other one none.
When they saw my cock, my friend said to the other woman: "I told you he has a big cock..."
But in Italian sounds better: "Te l'ho detto che questo ha la minchia grossa..."

 

[need2bsexy2]

I have been with 17 women. 10 of them commented on my size:

Look at you, you’re huge!!!
My God, you’re even bigger than your pictures.
You know, you’re bigger limp than most guys are hard.
That’s because you’re sooo big!
You have the most beautiful penis I have ever seen.
You’re so big!
Very nice, much bigger than my hubby.
Is it always that big?
Oh! You have a nice one! I love the gentle curve.
Oh my!

 

[SRX_10]

I've had 4 partners.. 1 that was a long term relationship always told me how good it was but never commented on the size... The other is my wife and the first time she saw it she stuffed it in her mouth and sucked it for a good 30-45 seconds, came up for air and told me "damn Babe your dick taste good!!!" Lol I love when she attempts to stuff my dick and balls in her mouth she always says "well if they weren't so big I could do it!!!"

 

[James Duncan]

"OMG! What am I supposed to do with that?! I can't even wrap my fingers around it!"

 

[deeperthanyou]

Making her cry from her first vaginal orgasm and finding her deep spot for her. Also being told "I finally feel filled up."

 

[buster67]

First that I remember , Her" I never knew anyone so skinny , could be so fat."

Then said we would have to wait for sex.

 

[D_F_Ng_Ghan]

First that I remember , Her" I never knew anyone so skinny , could be so fat."

Same here! I got a "You are slender, how could I imagine you are so fat down there?"

 

[parsec]

I met a girl at a party few years ago, we were both very drunk, and we ended up to her place.
She wanted to fuck, but was kinda "I'm not that kind of girl..." and all that crap. We fooled around for a while, then she took off my pants, she stared at it for a while, and then

"Fuck off, I want that!"

That was very turning on! After some drunk sex, and after she came, she said "please hurry you split me in half"... priceless!

 

[Italian1986]

One time I did sex with two women, once is a friend of mine and the other one none.
When they saw my cock, my friend said to the other woman: "I told you he has a big cock..."
But in Italian sounds better: "Te l'ho detto che questo ha la minchia grossa..."

Ahahahahaha GRANDE!!!

 

[Mr23]

My gf mouth dropped and she couldn't stop holding it and smiling. She kept playing with my balls too.

 

[amiable15]

i've been seeing a girl for a couple of months now. the first time we'd ever hooked up was at a friends house. we were both drunk out of our minds. we ended up hooking up. an event that i barely remember. the next time we hooked up she was over at my house, we were sober. when she pulled my boxers down, her eyes widened. and she asked "how the fuck did that fit in me last time??"

 

[bigocaramel22]

Ive been asked by a girl after sex "I was goonna ask you can you suck your own dick its sooo big"

 

[buster67]

Another I I also remember, was when she looked down after sex said"wow."And I said what. She just pointed and said " that , those , wow"

 

[RealConnoisseur]

So one day I asked my flat mates girlfriend to hook me up with one of her friends. She introduces me to the most desperate girl ever, I really wasn't attracted to her but I made nice while we were all out getting drinks and then called it a night. Turns out she fell for me pretty hard and then wouldn't leave me alone afterwards. I don't deal very well with rejecting people and I don't like being mean and she was basically trying to force me in to a relationship with her.

I managed to keep her at arms length for a while but one night we were partying and the flat mates gf had invited her without me knowing. The sheer amount of alcohol had got the best of me and we ended up in bed together. I slide inside her and she started moaning a lot, but it wasn't until I got her legs on my shoulder and pushed deep inside she was like "omg omg omg.... wait, wait wait wait...", I pushed a little deeper and felt that 'pop', she stops me again "oh my fucking god, I've never felt that before, what was that", I asked if it felt nice and she said it was amazing, and then proceeded to pound that spot as hard as I could for a while, she went absolutely nuts to say the least, writhing around in pleasure.

By the time I got her in to doggy she was just screaming and saying in a whimpering voice, "you're fucking huge", "you're so deep", "I've never felt this before" and so on.

I actually had to cover her mouth at various points because she was getting so loud that I knew the people staying over would be hearing this and it was making me pretty self conscious.

Needless to say, that night really didn't do me any favours with regard of getting rid of the girl, after that she kept turning up in my city randomly and trying to insert herself in to my life. In the end I had to have a word with the flat mates gf to get her to back down.

I ended up bumping in to her on a night out about a year after that and she was desperately trying to get me back to hers, she kept saying that she was over me now and she just wanted sex, but I just couldn't risk having to deal with that debacle again.

 

[ignatius4446z]

I've had lots of reactions:

Recently though two have stuck in my mind:


1. A former escort girl who said it was one of the three biggest she had ever encountered.

2. A doctor I was in a relationship for a while, and the first time she touched it she gasped and said "Oh, I'm in TROUBLE!", and then said "You do realise that's not normal, don't you?"

The funniest reaction was in my 20s when a one night stand girl took it out and without missing a beat she uttered that immortal line of Chief Brody's in Jaws - "We're gonna need a bigger boat."

 

[Uncutpete]

I've gotten great verbal reactions to my size from partners over the years, "I can't believe you're so big!" "Wow, that feels wonderful!" "No one has ever been that deep in me before." For me, though, the nicest reactions are the rolling repeated orgasms, that come from the deepest and widest possible fucking. Those, the ones where they black out, or cry after a row of huge climaxes, are my most satisfying reactions.

An ego-gratifying couple of reactions to my size came a few years ago when I was going to a string of orgy parties in my city. Once a beautiful European woman, with her husband next to her, had a bunch of guys lined up in front of her, all hard, she was stroking them in turn. I walked up and joined the men. She looked at my cock, stroked it a few times and said, "This is the man I want." I started a cuckold relationship with her and her husband that night. At another orgy, I walked up to a mat covered with fucking bodies. At the far end was a blonde girl in her twenties, kneeling but straightened up and looking over them. She looked me up and down... and down... and said, "you're beautiful, will you come here and fuck me, please?"

 

[helmholtz]

One of the best for me was when I was dry humping a girl I met online (we are both around 30). She had her skirt up, panties on, I was in cargo shorts. I ground against her over and over until she finally said "I want it, I want it.". I let it spring free and she just let out a moan, damn near ripped her panties off and wrapped her legs around me. Three minutes later she was cumming and half whispering/half crying "Oh, it's soo big." She was tight and I could feel her clamp down when she came. It set me off quickly. That was pretty damn good for my ego, which isn't always in perfect standing. It's amazing what a few compliments will do for a guy