Best reaction to your size for the first time (legal age only)

[72361]

A college girlfriend who took my pants off, saw the bulge in my underwear. She exclaimed "holy shit!" and her attitude suddenly turned coy and nervous.

 

[drunkhusky]

I had been dating this girl for a few months and we were taking it slow. she was a tiny thing, like 5 ft 2 and 100 lbs top, mid-twenties and relatively inexperienced. we drank a bottle of wine, started fooling around, she sends me to the store to get condoms and lube, i get back, shes naked in bed, i rip my cloths off jump into bed and she looks at me and “im gonna need another drink or two before i take that.” we ended getting dressed and going to a bar up before having an amazing night

 

[7086261]

In my puberty my cock was always the biggest.
Every time I changed clothes after school sports, the boys looked at it and said: Why is he so big or I want a dick like that too.

 

[jackie_p]

"You're porn sized"

 

[Iga]

Making out with a guy and my pants dropped. I always downplayed my cock size thinking it was average. As soon as he grabbed my bulge, he broke from our kiss to let out a “holy fuck you’re thick!”

I topped him every time we fucked that summer.

 

[Notaes]

Everytime I have had sex with a guy they always comment on my size. They say I’m large which I don’t buy it. I think some guys just tell you what you want to hear.

 

[udubcrew]

While holding my soft cock after sex: “I’ve been with guys who are this size and super proud of it...”

 

[Adomfg]

While holding my soft cock after sex: “I’ve been with guys who are this size and super proud of it...”

Dude, I remember in the old "Best reaction to your size the first time" thread, you used to post a ton of really good first time reactions.

Please post more of your reactions ?

Thanks a lot man, and kind regards,
Andrew

 

[udubcrew]

Dude, I remember in the old "Best reaction to your size the first time" thread, you used to post a ton of really good first time reactions.

Please post more of your reactions ?

Thanks a lot man, and kind regards,
Andrew

I just don't sleep around the way I used to!

 

[NerdyDCLoner]

Recently
My new lady, when we first had sex and I whipped it out her eyes just got really big and I ask her ,"what?"

Nothing she says
And then we proceeded to have hours of sex

Then after a round, as we lay next to each other, she grabs my dick and starts stroking it saying I'm well above average and did I always have such a big dick
I tell her I have but that I think I'm like, "normal big"

No she laughs holding out her forearm... It's really really big

And she literally keeps stroking me and tells me how I'm so big and not just big, but I know how to use it and fill her pussy to brim

She questioned the depth of her pussy

 

[CuriousDad123]

Best response was “Holyshit! You’re as thick as my beer can. Idk if I can take you.”

 

[NM8x6]

Probably my favorite ever was a guy who was sucking me. I had forced him down fully on my cock and he started to struggle a little. I let up and he came up gasping. Once he caught his breath, he said, "That's a lot of cock, sir."

 

[JoshHung]

My favorites have been when they just start stuttering. That's happened a few times.

Also the non-verbal ones. Their eyes just lock on it like they can't believe it and they take a gulp.

 

[IrishWank]

These expeinces are fun to read. I read the posts then go check the pics to see who's dick lives up to the story and amd who might be exaggerating a little. Theres a lot of hidden treasures in this thread lol Lots of big dicks being discreet on here.

 

[Adomfg]

"Nice cock" - And then she smiled. From a sweet prostitute in a brothel.

 

[HungMuscleHuge]

I get.. “I’m embarrassed to call myself a man around you.”... a lot

 

[chub4chub340]

I get.. “I’m embarrassed to call myself a man around you.”... a lot

Having just looked at your pics, I can see why! wow

 

[3HandsfulofDick]

Many things have been said but my favorites I get all the time:

1. “Who else you giving the dick to?”. “With dick that big and good you can’t tell me you don’t have others out there you fuckin

2. “Will u be in town this weekend”?

“Yes”

“Im at the grocery store... What would you like for me to cook”..

Nothing like to see a big muscular man in the kitchen ass naked with an Apron on cooking for you ...My last meal (Just this past Tuesday morning: meat lovers omelette with crispy hash browns in the inside, a big bowl of grits with homemade biscuits on the side with butter and jam).

3. “You are definately on your grown man shit”

4. “How old did you say you were? Don’t know to many 50 year olds still in their prime”

5. King, papi, daddy.. The usual shit that didn’t mean anything until it was explained to me...Like my women and men have said... “Having a big dick doesn’t make u a daddy/papi” “Role play has nothing to do with being called Daddy”.. Being old doesn’t make u a daddy... That’s a title that is earned”.. Who the fuck am I to argue...

 

[Adomfg]

bump.

 

[Serpentlike]

At 19 I fucked a coworker and saw her at work the next day. She said she still couldn't walk right. lol