Best reaction to your size for the first time (legal age only)

lilcamel

Legendary Member
Verified
Gold
Joined
Sep 30, 2017
Posts
359
Media
11
Likes
1,313
Points
413
Location
New York (United States)
Verification
View
Sexuality
60% Straight, 40% Gay
Gender
Male
Best reaction was with my wife, actually. We'd already been married a few years, and had been sexually active while dating before that.

After a night of drinking one night, we came home and got a little frisky. I asked her to blow me, and she got down on her knees but then just gave me a handjob for a minute or two. I asked "Is something wrong?"

She looked up at me with her big (slightly drunk) eyes and says, "... You're just really fucking big," with the most sincere voice. Goes to show you can still be surprised by your wife (and surprise her too, it seems!)
Hot love to get a peek at what she saw. Love to see her looking up and realizing? Fuck me he his hung!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: MDM8

Robert Dole

Cherished Member
Joined
Sep 14, 2023
Posts
158
Media
0
Likes
358
Points
98
Location
Auckland, Auckland, NZ
Sexuality
No Response
In my early 30s with a woman 10 years older, she had been flirty for some months and when I eventually responded we ended up at her place after a night out. I'd had a limited amount of experience with women at that stage, one girl before I left home and my housemate's sister before I had discovered cock and neither had said anything although my bulging had been an issue when I was younger. We were sitting on the porch outside in the dark, kissing and exploring when she undid my pants and found my hard cock. She didn't make any comment but her hand stayed there while I rubbed her nipples and explored her pussy, encouraged by her body movements and subtle responses.
Eventually we moved into the bedroom and I soon started fucking her standing, leaning her against the bed end. Things were going well after a few minutes and she was relaxed, making appreciative noises as well as plenty of juice. I was soon feeling that I was stopping mid stroke so lifted her up and gently lowered her onto my cock, instinctively she wrapped her legs around me and gasped as I bottomed out. A few strokes later she cried out and gripped me tightly as she came, I let her recover for a moment before continuing to fuck her and she soon came again, squirting this time and sending me over the edge, her pussy seemed to spasm as I delivered several shots deep inside. She babbled about "so much cock", seemed a bit dazed and started crying after I laid her on the bed.
She was so keen the next morning, and even more so after I'd made her wait until evening- I could smell her pussy all the way to her place in the car, and she was ready to go long before we got inside...
 

Magnum10x2

Mythical Member
Joined
Feb 3, 2006
Posts
15,444
Media
2
Likes
68,965
Points
418
Sexuality
100% Straight, 0% Gay
Gender
Male
Not the "BEST" but a recent one was after a few weeks of traveling and no sex...

Kissing passionately, she wiggles out of her tiny lace underwear, and I start to play with her clit to get her really wet and start loosening her up a bit. A few minutes go by, and she reaches down and starts playing with my cock - strokes and rubs it... grabs it by the base and wiggles it back and forth and stops kissing me, looks me in the eyes, and says - I forgot how fucking big you are.

Instantly flipped her around and started 69ing.....
 

kahlua123

Loved Member
Joined
Oct 13, 2013
Posts
135
Media
12
Likes
554
Points
263
Sexuality
100% Straight, 0% Gay
Gender
Male
That is a HUGE size man!! I’m sure the neighbors will hear her for sure!! Good luck! @kahlua123!!
It was! I got a bit more length than usual (almost 8.75) and a little less girth than I hoped (a hair over 7), and we did fuck...unfortunately, she was self-conscious lol she tried her best to be quiet and mostly succeeded:neutral: I swear this woman is a bottomless pit
 

Jimbob7.7

Expert Member
Joined
May 8, 2021
Posts
25
Media
0
Likes
175
Points
38
Location
United Kingdom
Sexuality
100% Straight, 0% Gay
Gender
Male
OK, so this isn't the first time, but it was yesterday morning and a pretty good one though.

Through a few reasons beyond our control, me and the wife hadn't had sex for about a month. Opportunity finally arrived yesterday morning though, and she came in the bedroom and stripped naked and jiggled her massive boob's at me with a chuckle then lay on the bed. It was time!!

Within seconds my head was between her legs licking furiously. When it was time to put it in I did the usual method of getting the first couple of inches past her opening then waiting for a few seconds as I feel her relax and she adjusts. Then I push the rest in as far as it will go and wait some more before I can start thrusting. Finally I started doing the long strokes from tip to base that she loves.

When I eventually stop to adjust us into a slightly different position she says to me "I feel like a virgin every time you put it in after it's been a while." I replied "is that because you feel a bit tight?" To which she says "because I have to get used to your cock again!"
 

MDM8

Worshipped Member
Verified
Gold
Joined
Jan 21, 2021
Posts
1,361
Media
451
Likes
14,576
Points
408
Location
Dublin (California, United States)
Verification
View
Sexuality
100% Straight, 0% Gay
Gender
Male
OK, so this isn't the first time, but it was yesterday morning and a pretty good one though.

Through a few reasons beyond our control, me and the wife hadn't had sex for about a month. Opportunity finally arrived yesterday morning though, and she came in the bedroom and stripped naked and jiggled her massive boob's at me with a chuckle then lay on the bed. It was time!!

Within seconds my head was between her legs licking furiously. When it was time to put it in I did the usual method of getting the first couple of inches past her opening then waiting for a few seconds as I feel her relax and she adjusts. Then I push the rest in as far as it will go and wait some more before I can start thrusting. Finally I started doing the long strokes from tip to base that she loves.

When I eventually stop to adjust us into a slightly different position she says to me "I feel like a virgin every time you put it in after it's been a while." I replied "is that because you feel a bit tight?" To which she says "because I have to get used to your cock again!"
That sounds exactly like my wife and I. She always has to adjust and I have to take it slow when it has been a while. Love it!!
 

rocketj

Cherished Member
Verified
Gold
Joined
Nov 5, 2011
Posts
103
Media
4
Likes
328
Points
393
Location
Baytown (Texas, United States)
Verification
View
Gender
Male
I started off on another hook-up site.
You could cam with other members. It was cool. I'm very reserved in my daily life but have a kinkier side in private. I like to show off...and sometimes even shit talk if I feel like it.

I get...
"It's fuckin' huge."
"Can I suck it."
"Damn, daddy."

The funniest was, "Damn, that's a big ol' dick".

My favorite was just a simple
"Damn, that's big."
 

lapdog2001

Worshipped Member
Gold
Platinum Gold
Joined
Jun 30, 2004
Posts
5,718
Media
15
Likes
13,352
Points
643
Location
Massachusetts (United States)
Sexuality
100% Straight, 0% Gay
Gender
Male
Best reaction was with my wife, actually.
She looked up at me with her big (slightly drunk) eyes and says, "... You're just really fucking big," with the most sincere voice. Goes to show you can still be surprised by your wife (and surprise her too, it seems!)
Same with me after 10 years. Lying in bed the other morning she reaches over and caresses my chest and stomach before noticing my semi- snaking down the leg of the stretchy nylon boxers I wear to bed. "That thing is amazing...simply amazing!"
Same with my wife, after almost 20 years! More than half the time when we are getting sexual with each other, she makes a comment about how magnificent my cock is. I enjoy foreplay, but once my wife gets my cock in her hands and how hard she has made it, she really wants it inside her right now! Who am I to argue!
 

stretch8888

Legendary Member
Joined
Feb 28, 2017
Posts
518
Media
0
Likes
1,797
Points
213
Location
Vancouver (British Columbia, Canada)
Sexuality
100% Straight, 0% Gay
Gender
Male
Not the best but most recent and good for the ego

Recently single and one of the first women i hooked up with was an old friend of my ex[who was 26]. This former friend, 35, single mother, great body, small tits but she does her squats and has an incredible ass, we got along great but her and my ex had a bit of a falling out just different life styles AND she thought the friend was a little to flirty with me.

Turns out she was flirting hard, i have a bit of a dad bod which she is into and a big cock that my ex talked about a lot. I started chatting her up and she says we can hang out some time if i need someone to talk to or something, i take her up on that, we get some beers a pizza and put on a movie.

Maybe ten minutes in she starts snuggling up and says "if it's too soon i understand....but we can fuck if you want to" she didn't have to say anything else, we were all over each other, it was hot and quick right there on the couch her on top, we both had orgasms and as we're catching our breath my cock still inside her she says "So how do you feel about fucking me say 3 or 4 times a week?"
 

drambone2001

Worshipped Member
Joined
May 31, 2004
Posts
5,530
Media
23
Likes
12,686
Points
368
Location
Kitchener (Ontario, Canada)
Sexuality
No Response
Gender
Male
Not the best but most recent and good for the ego

Recently single and one of the first women i hooked up with was an old friend of my ex[who was 26]. This former friend, 35, single mother, great body, small tits but she does her squats and has an incredible ass, we got along great but her and my ex had a bit of a falling out just different life styles AND she thought the friend was a little to flirty with me.

Turns out she was flirting hard, i have a bit of a dad bod which she is into and a big cock that my ex talked about a lot. I started chatting her up and she says we can hang out some time if i need someone to talk to or something, i take her up on that, we get some beers a pizza and put on a movie.

Maybe ten minutes in she starts snuggling up and says "if it's too soon i understand....but we can fuck if you want to" she didn't have to say anything else, we were all over each other, it was hot and quick right there on the couch her on top, we both had orgasms and as we're catching our breath my cock still inside her she says "So how do you feel about fucking me say 3 or 4 times a week?"
I got a huge hardon reading this. I can feel the heat between you two all the way up here!
 

Dirkdiggler10x7

Legendary Member
Joined
Nov 6, 2020
Posts
169
Media
6
Likes
1,654
Points
288
Location
New York (United States)
Sexuality
100% Straight, 0% Gay
Gender
Male
This is definitely some of the best part of being well hung or really hung. The shocking surprise reaction by girls mixed with a bit of panic concern followed by excitement and lore. Especially as a slender/athletic white guy in the earlier internet days
The first that started my recollection of women reaction wasn’t even an immediate reaction. Instead it was on a road trip in college to visit this girl my friend was friends with up in providence. Well end of the night her super hot friend who was known to enjoy a good bang, ended up getting me as a guest in her dorm room. We’re both hammer and end up banging a couple times. A couple weeks later her recollection of the night and story she told her girlfriend gets related to my buddy. All of a sudden I’m known as mr king dong.
The first immediate reaction that left a memory was summed before senior year of college. I had lived in Boston for the summer and it was the last night before moving home and then moving back to college. This Cute petite girl I worked with and I had been flirting for a couple weeks. Just so happens someone was having a party that night and she was there. She was actually my second “goal” for the night but wanted to bang her. Started talking and decided to grab a drink at bar down the street from my apt. I end up seeing if she wanted to grab a shot of whatever the popular bpoze was at the time. Go back do a shot and sitting on couch. My 4 roommates were all asleep and I shared a bedroom with someone so if this was gonna happen it was gonna happen in the living room on the couch. Next thing you know we start making out and grabbing body parts. Tits come out her pants start coming down and then she finally reaches for my crotch. My cock is super hard and 21 year old large. Through my jeans she feels my cock and says and I quote “what is that?”
Me “ it’s my cock what do you think it is”
Her “ no way it’s way too big. What else is there besides your Cock”
Me” nothing it’s just my cock. Why what’s the Problem”
Her “the problem is if that’s only your cock ummm its HUUUUGGGGEEEE”
Me “I mean if you don’t believe me here I’ll show you”
Her” ok show me cause if that’s all you then oh my god.
I proceed to take off jeans and she marvels. Think I’m real now. Tell her to finish up. She then takes off my boxers with my huge cock springing free and her eyes burst out of her head. “ oh my god it’s enormous.”
Me “ thanks I guess
We proceed to fuck for like 10 mins. I busy but stayed hard and kept fucking. And we go on for another like 20 or kore mins. I couldn’t bust and it was so late bc I was hammered. At which point, for the only time ever in my life, I faked an orgasm. She has cummed all over me like 5 times so I knew she was good.
Anyway that was definitely one of the first reactions that was great
 

lilcamel

Legendary Member
Verified
Gold
Joined
Sep 30, 2017
Posts
359
Media
11
Likes
1,313
Points
413
Location
New York (United States)
Verification
View
Sexuality
60% Straight, 40% Gay
Gender
Male
This is definitely some of the best part of being well hung or really hung. The shocking surprise reaction by girls mixed with a bit of panic concern followed by excitement and lore. Especially as a slender/athletic white guy in the earlier internet days
The first that started my recollection of women reaction wasn’t even an immediate reaction. Instead it was on a road trip in college to visit this girl my friend was friends with up in providence. Well end of the night her super hot friend who was known to enjoy a good bang, ended up getting me as a guest in her dorm room. We’re both hammer and end up banging a couple times. A couple weeks later her recollection of the night and story she told her girlfriend gets related to my buddy. All of a sudden I’m known as mr king dong.
The first immediate reaction that left a memory was summed before senior year of college. I had lived in Boston for the summer and it was the last night before moving home and then moving back to college. This Cute petite girl I worked with and I had been flirting for a couple weeks. Just so happens someone was having a party that night and she was there. She was actually my second “goal” for the night but wanted to bang her. Started talking and decided to grab a drink at bar down the street from my apt. I end up seeing if she wanted to grab a shot of whatever the popular bpoze was at the time. Go back do a shot and sitting on couch. My 4 roommates were all asleep and I shared a bedroom with someone so if this was gonna happen it was gonna happen in the living room on the couch. Next thing you know we start making out and grabbing body parts. Tits come out her pants start coming down and then she finally reaches for my crotch. My cock is super hard and 21 year old large. Through my jeans she feels my cock and says and I quote “what is that?”
Me “ it’s my cock what do you think it is”
Her “ no way it’s way too big. What else is there besides your Cock”
Me” nothing it’s just my cock. Why what’s the Problem”
Her “the problem is if that’s only your cock ummm its HUUUUGGGGEEEE”
Me “I mean if you don’t believe me here I’ll show you”
Her” ok show me cause if that’s all you then oh my god.
I proceed to take off jeans and she marvels. Think I’m real now. Tell her to finish up. She then takes off my boxers with my huge cock springing free and her eyes burst out of her head. “ oh my god it’s enormous.”
Me “ thanks I guess
We proceed to fuck for like 10 mins. I busy but stayed hard and kept fucking. And we go on for another like 20 or kore mins. I couldn’t bust and it was so late bc I was hammered. At which point, for the only time ever in my life, I faked an orgasm. She has cummed all over me like 5 times so I knew she was good.
Anyway that was definitely one of the first reactions that was great
fuck i want to see that cock
 

DrJacoby

Loved Member
Verified
Gold
Joined
Sep 18, 2006
Posts
46
Media
22
Likes
637
Points
403
Verification
View
Sexuality
90% Straight, 10% Gay
Gender
Male
Early on in our relationship, me and my gf were lying in bed making out. She unzipped my pants and pulled my dick out to stroke it. We were in a slightly uncomfortable position, so she had me take my pants off and bring my stuff up to her. So I straddled her, kneeling, and awkwardly shuffled forward. Suddenly she was suddenly face-to-face with my hard dick, which was swinging from back and forth as I got closer. She said “whoooa! It’s… big!” It was such a cute, sincere reaction that it’s permanently branded in my memory. Some years later we smoked weed and were messing around in the living room in full daylight and she got really transfixed looking at it like she’d never seen it before. She held it in her hand and said “oh my god, it’s really big! It’s too big!,” then laughed like a maniac.

I’ve had girls play up their reactions before but she’s not the kind of person who does dirty talk so I know whenever she mentions my size, she’s simply stating a fact. I find that way hotter!
 

nomju

Legendary Member
Joined
Jan 5, 2011
Posts
322
Media
33
Likes
1,736
Points
423
Location
Sheffield, England
Sexuality
100% Straight, 0% Gay
Gender
Male
Not her initial reaction. She did make some comment about my size when she first saw it, but the first time I fucked this woman I hooked up with (mid 30s, mother of 3), she wanted to be in control, so she went on top. As she lowered herself onto me, and I entered her, she shouted out 'JEEEEEZUS CHRIST'
 

drambone2001

Worshipped Member
Joined
May 31, 2004
Posts
5,530
Media
23
Likes
12,686
Points
368
Location
Kitchener (Ontario, Canada)
Sexuality
No Response
Gender
Male
This is definitely some of the best part of being well hung or really hung. The shocking surprise reaction by girls mixed with a bit of panic concern followed by excitement and lore. Especially as a slender/athletic white guy in the earlier internet days
The first that started my recollection of women reaction wasn’t even an immediate reaction. Instead it was on a road trip in college to visit this girl my friend was friends with up in providence. Well end of the night her super hot friend who was known to enjoy a good bang, ended up getting me as a guest in her dorm room. We’re both hammer and end up banging a couple times. A couple weeks later her recollection of the night and story she told her girlfriend gets related to my buddy. All of a sudden I’m known as mr king dong.
The first immediate reaction that left a memory was summed before senior year of college. I had lived in Boston for the summer and it was the last night before moving home and then moving back to college. This Cute petite girl I worked with and I had been flirting for a couple weeks. Just so happens someone was having a party that night and she was there. She was actually my second “goal” for the night but wanted to bang her. Started talking and decided to grab a drink at bar down the street from my apt. I end up seeing if she wanted to grab a shot of whatever the popular bpoze was at the time. Go back do a shot and sitting on couch. My 4 roommates were all asleep and I shared a bedroom with someone so if this was gonna happen it was gonna happen in the living room on the couch. Next thing you know we start making out and grabbing body parts. Tits come out her pants start coming down and then she finally reaches for my crotch. My cock is super hard and 21 year old large. Through my jeans she feels my cock and says and I quote “what is that?”
Me “ it’s my cock what do you think it is”
Her “ no way it’s way too big. What else is there besides your Cock”
Me” nothing it’s just my cock. Why what’s the Problem”
Her “the problem is if that’s only your cock ummm its HUUUUGGGGEEEE”
Me “I mean if you don’t believe me here I’ll show you”
Her” ok show me cause if that’s all you then oh my god.
I proceed to take off jeans and she marvels. Think I’m real now. Tell her to finish up. She then takes off my boxers with my huge cock springing free and her eyes burst out of her head. “ oh my god it’s enormous.”
Me “ thanks I guess
We proceed to fuck for like 10 mins. I busy but stayed hard and kept fucking. And we go on for another like 20 or kore mins. I couldn’t bust and it was so late bc I was hammered. At which point, for the only time ever in my life, I faked an orgasm. She has cummed all over me like 5 times so I knew she was good.
Anyway that was definitely one of the first reactions that was great
Absolutely rocking! Primacy of the 21-year-old LP !!!
 

1randombeauty

Superior Member
Joined
May 10, 2020
Posts
2,150
Media
62
Likes
9,390
Points
558
Location
Zimbabwe
Sexuality
100% Straight, 0% Gay
I have shared some reactions to my cock in this thread, but one of my favorites involves my wife and a new toy I bought her, the lifelike Alberto Blanco Dildo. We were in bed kissing and feeling each other with me really focusing on her nice natural boobs when I said, “I got you a new toy.” To which she responded, “Really?” So I asked her if she wanted to see it and she said, “ok.” So I turned over to grab it from the nightstand. When I rolled back over I took it out of the box and brought it up between us, so very close to her face. Her initial response was incredibly sexy. She said, “That is really big, we’re going to need some lotion.” The look on her face was priceless. But what she did next was the hottest. Literally within 45 seconds or a minute of taking the massive cock out of the box and making her initial comment she brought it down between her legs and started rubbing her pussy with it. Before long I was sliding the realistic cock in and out of my wife’s tight pussy. She came so good and I was as hard as I’ve ever been watching her work it into her little body until she had it all and enjoying. A really, really fun and sexy time with my wife.