Madame Zora- I agree with liking the compliments, but for me its got to be after the fact, not some girl that just heard about me.
For example, I loved it when the girl I lost my virginity with said afterwards "I put my hand on it and didn't think it would fit inside me" (she wasn't a virgin, but I was)
But, this other girl later in life that I always had an eye on was talking to me one night and said "I'd have sex with any guy I found attractive that had a decent package". In the context of the conversation, that was my green light and I never made a move. (she knew a little about me from other girls)
I like it when a girl I'm dating compliments my size, but I hate it when a girl that has never been with me makes a comment about wanting to sleep with me because of my penis. Sure it's kind of flattering and ego boosting but its also very shallow of the girl, and shallow women do not turn me on.
I guess what it boils down to for me is if it's a compliment from her being pleasantly suprised, its flattering. If its a comment about wanting to sleep with me for the first time because of it its a turn off.