EscapeGoat:
It seems strange that you don't feel satisfied because you can't take him all the way in, yet at the same time you know that his size causes trouble for you.
Helloo, new here... I decided to reply because this caught my eye.
I think I may know what judy meant, because I can relate to her statement. I have a boyfriend who bottoms out if he goes all the way in. The trouble is, that if he doesn't go all the way in, his pelvis never touches mine (in the missionary position) and it's that touching and grinding, and the clitoral stimulation that comes with it, that's my sole means of orgasm. It's the part I enjoy most about sex. And it's something that I haven't yet figured out a way to do with my boyfriend, because when he goes all the way in, it's very painful, and I often end up bleeding after sex because of it. The clit is simply in a place, on me at least, where it only gets touched if my partner is in up to the hilt.
I know there are lots of women who get much pleasure from the penetration alone, and the various spots to rub inside. But the clit is there to give lots of pleasure also, and to have it go unstimulated during sex is a problem. :\
Judy may have meant something else though.

I could be wrong.