Mate I agree with nearly all what you have said as I am long term fan of this site. I took ages to join, due to the restrictions in the UK, and did for 7 years from 2009. Then I got some of the newer scenes via My Vidster thereafter. When that dried up, I again tried to rejoin in 2019 , but it was again restricted.
All of the pictures you showed were from that time when the site was at its best. The scenes were perfect fantasy of the Straight Man next door being ‘abused’ and fucked in the ass. And the pain they experienced looked real it was not faked although controlled as the interviews always stated.
The only bit I not agree with is gay whining as I know some of the guys from that time are not straight as I encounter number of them in the UK, and they are as gay as I am. All of the new guys are professional porn models form 2017, and Dave the Master with the cropped hair and Adrian the bald master are gay men controlling the supposing innocent Straight Guys.
P.S. when I get a chance I will upload some scenes if I am allowed to of course.