I'm dumbfounded by what is an ample amount of carats for an engagement ring without it looking gaudy. Any advice? And how the hell do I get her ring size without her knowing???
I'm dumbfounded by what is an ample amount of carats for an engagement ring without it looking gaudy. Any advice? And how the hell do I get her ring size without her knowing???[/QUOTE] It really depends on your budget; but IMHO the center stone should be at least one carat and of the best quality you can afford. Better a smaller diamond of excellent clarity than a larger one with visible flaws.
The best way that I know of to get thecorrect finger size for that Engagement Ring is to ask her Best Friend and if that doesn't work, ask her Mother!
BUT, you've got to get them to swear to total confidentiality! Once they know it's an Engagement Ring and a proposal is coming, they'll zip their lips quicker than you can say "Zip it!"
How to Buy an Engagement Diamond in 12 Simple Sentences
http://www.ehow.com/how_5012398_buy-engagement-diamond-simple-sentences.html
So if you go into a jewelry store that has a bridal section Ask to see what they have in a 1 carat round G-H SI1 category and take it from there.I agree buy a diamond, unless she has expressed interest in another stone, woman want "the rock" Again three months salary is a general guide. Diamonds come in colors the F-G and even some of the H stones are still very white and clean looking. You then have to deal with clarity of the stone, VVSI 1 means that the stone will be very very slightly included there are still beautiful SI 1 stones which means it's slightly included. You then have to determine the shape, round in the most popular. and at last but not least carat weight. A carat or 1.0 tcw is a beautiful ring. To get her size check out her jewelry box or a ring that would fit her ring finger, then slip it on one of your own fingers and see where it fits and when you go to buy the ring slip it on your finger. You also have to determine if you want the ring in 18K white or yellow gold. What does she wear more of white or yellow gold? My advice with engagement rings is platinum it's sturdy and will endure a lifetime of wear.When you give an engagement ring she will want to wear it and not have to take it off for sizing. BTW Congratulations!
The internet is this amazing place. Do a search on diamonds. The basic four c'sI'm dumbfounded by what is an ample amount of carats for an engagement ring without it looking gaudy. Any advice? And how the hell do I get her ring size without her knowing???
Wow a 3 carat diamond that old. Pretty impressive. The thing about the old diamonds is they didn't play with them as much. They were what they were. Not a bad idea, but I can see either way as some people want to be the first owner.I would think a very high quality diamond in the one carat range would be nice. But I am not a huge fan buying a new diamond.
My first fiancee got a 3 carat diamond and platinum ring that belonged to my great grandmother. That was a surprise for her and she loved it.
The second one knew we were going to get married so i surprised her with a trip to "The Goldsmith" in Chicago so she could try things on and see what she liked. She ended up with a 1930s 4 carat pale blue sapphire surrounded in diamonds set in platinum. There are excellent engagement rings that are older and classic, but it all depends on her style and personality and of course what you can comfortably afford.
Good luck and keep us posted!
I agree with you on everyhting you have to say except about not buying the ring and presenting it to her when he proposes. Every girl would like to have a ring presented to her when a man proposes. I really do not think he is worried about her saying no. That rarely happens. I amsure he has an idea of her feelings becasue most men wouldn't propose if they thought the answer may be no.The sum spent is traditionally 3 months of your earnings. You can either go with a large stone of lesser quality or a smaller stone of higher quality. You may choose to get a diamond or another type of stone. Setting is important too. Like shoes, women notice these things where men usually don't.
All in all, I say propose first and then go engagement ring shopping. That way you can find out what stones she likes, what styles, and what metal to pair the stone with. It also means that if she declines your proposal you're not stuck with an expensive memento of a failed relationship. The idea of presenting her with a ring is romantic but impractical for most people. By letting her in on the process she'll get a ring she likes and it shows respectful consideration for her taste.
Good luck!
Excellent advice! Although I am partial to the traditional 6-prong Tiffany type setting. IMHO round diamonds often look square in a 4-prong setting.So if you go into a jewelry store that has a bridal section Ask to see what they have in a 1 carat round G-H SI1 category and take it from there.
I would think a very high quality diamond in the one carat range would be nice.
But I am not a huge fan buying a new diamond.
A family heirloom (of any size) is always a welcome surprise for a bride to be! It helps to calm any qualms that she may have about his family accepting her. In some familys grandmas ring will not be given without full approval from his side of the family.My first fiancee got a 3 carat diamond and platinum ring that belonged to my great grandmother. That was a surprise for her and she loved it.
While I am fond of antique and estate jewelry; I think I'd rather have something simple that won't look out of place worn everyday for the rest of my life.The second one knew we were going to get married so i surprised her with a trip to "The Goldsmith" in Chicago so she could try things on and see what she liked. She ended up with a 1930s 4 carat pale blue sapphire surrounded in diamonds set in platinum. There are excellent engagement rings that are older and classic, but it all depends on her style and personality and of course what you can comfortably afford.Good luck and keep us posted!
OK, here's all I know. When I was dating my now second-wife, I was looking at rings until I was cross-eyed. I wanted it to be something special, so I examined settings and bands and all sorts of stuff.
Excellent advice!Out of the blue I get a call from a very close friend and I finally tell her what I'm doing. All she says is "Get a rock." That's it, just get a rock, a solitaire. No fancy bands, no flower petals, no chips or bunches of diamonds. A simple one-carat solitaire of sufficient quality, no less than an I, and you're good to go.Wifey verifies that this is fact.
I'm dumbfounded by what is an ample amount of carats for an engagement ring without it looking gaudy. Any advice? And how the hell do I get her ring size without her knowing???
I'm guessing she actually does want a diamond engagement ring? I know I didn't...
Ok where do you live?She wants a diamond ring. She actually showed me what she likes which can be seen in the movie "Two Lovers". It's a simple single diamond solitaire that looks like about half a carat.
I am going with my best friend to pick out the ring in September. I really don't want to spend 10K on the ring even though I can probably afford it. The ring needs to be simple. I do plan to go out and just look at rings but I just wanted to get a consensus of what is too small from people here who may know.