Man! I love this thread, so many good and fun stories. Please keep it going guys.
I haven’t been catfished yet, well at least not to the extend that some of y’all have experienced. Mine turned out quite well!
When I was 19yo, I chatted with an older guy on gaydar whom I thought was a 38yo guy, that was what was shown on his profile. We exchanged a few pics. He only shown his torso up to his neck, his body was fit, mascular with a nice chest hair. I liked fit mature looking men with hairy chest back in the day and I still do. Such a big turn on!
Anyway, we agreed to meet up. I was quite nervous about this whole because I was quite insecure about my looks at that age. I had a lean swimmer build (and I still do) with broad shoulders and been told that I’m cute and turned a few heads walking down the streets back in the day. Anyway, his car pulled up next to the footpath and he rolled down his car window. My first impression of him was, he looked abit older than 38yo, more like 42 to 45yo. He also had a moustache, I wasn’t expecting that because I rarely seen any men with moustache. That aside, he was a hot daddy! He looked like a mature jock daddy from one of those falcon gay porn movies, he was rocking an army buzz cut with chiseled face and jawline. I loved clean cut army looking men and I can’t stand men with long hairs.
He asked me to get in his car and I asked him where we were going. He said his place! I was estatic but I didn’t let it show. I asked him what If i didn’t look like my photos, what would he have done? He said he’ll just drive away leaving me at the train station and block my mob number. We got to his place and we sat on the couch, as excited as i was finally hooking up with a guy, a hot guy at that, i was a bit uneasy about the whole thing since it was my first time. So he put on some gay horror flick and we sat close together. And the next thing I knew, he had his hand in my brief, so I tried to crop a feel of his bulge and he was wearing 2 layers of underwears, boxer shorts and briefs underneath. I put my hand inside his boxer shorts and man, his bulge was moist and wet. His cock was about 7 to 8 inches, cut and thick. We just jerked off because I didn’t feel too comfortable going all the way with him.
I met up with him again when I was about 24 or 25. I got his personal email so I hit him up. He responded and agreed to meet up. He picked me up and we went to his new fancy apartment. He took off his pant the second we walked inside the room with a big smile. I was hoping to relive my first encounter with him, with the teasing and all before showing everything. He had gained a fair bit of weight, his body was still mascular but was more chunky and less defined looking. His face was softer, less chiseled and rounder looking. I didn’t mind that because we all get old someday.
Long story short. A month ago while I was browsing through some gay profiles, I saw his nickname again and sure enough, it was him. I was happy to see that he’s still alive because I was concerned that he may have passed away from skin cancer due to his excessive sun tanning. 2 in 3 Australians are diagnosed with skin cancer by the age of 70.
The thing that shocked me was his age, the profile shown that he’s 41 yo this year. Dude! He’s 51yo at the very least if he really was 38yo when I first met him. I don’t know why he would feel the need to lie about his age? He seemed pretty sensible and well educated. He’s a good looking bloke with money!
Now that i’m almost 32yo, I do feel a bit embarassed about revealing my age when asked but I would never lie about it. I’m now only into men around my age, give or take a few years. One thing is for certain, now i give extra points to men rocking moustache. I find it irresistibly hot and sexy!! The hookups with him really influenced my taste in men.