Conscious attempts at masculinity are transparent and deeply unattractive.

None of these activities are my thing. That said I would never presume to know what motivates guys to do what they do. If it makes them happy then why would I care? I have not been given the scepter of judgement and am happy to let others pursue a life that makes them fulfilled.
 
Aren't you noble?

Everyone makes judgments of other people. It's insincere to pretend you don't.

I think, when a guy has to wear particular items of clothing to assert his "masculinity", you can be pretty certain he's overcompensating...