Thanks Jeff - that's a very thorough explanation of where you're coming from.
I think it is intersting both Jeff and David see it in similar ways - that there is somewhere a line that gets crossed between 'person who enjoys sex' and 'slut'.
Looking at responses here and in the other thread about sluts I find it curious that all of us (even when, like Jeff [and I'd say me too], we try not to judge) feel that there is such thing as a slut but that the definition is really vague - and often shifts depending on several factors.
For some people it appears to be about number of partners over a given time - that is what milf is asking us to consider. She is also asking us to consider the relationships she had with the men she has had sex with. She even considers two incidents that many would consider rape in her list that we should judge her on (even though her consent was not given)*. Both in this thread and the other, people are discussing the motivation for sex, the choice of partner, their feelings for the person who may or may not be considered a slut, and so on.
Looking at the highly objective way that this is judged socially, even by the open minded, starts me wondering if sluts exist at all. Is it not just a term we use, mainly for women but more these days for men too, to define a sexual behaviour that we don't understand? There are a few people who take the term and apply it to themselves (usually defiantly) but most of us do not think of ourselves as sluts and define slut as something else. And who is to say why a person feels the need / want of many partners - who is to say (if that needs comes from insecurity, sexual energy, an inability to be close without sexual contact, or something else) that it is something to be judged entirely negatively. Like Jeff says, he feels different about the people he feels he understands / knows - How can we judge the motivations of people when we don't know the full story?
I don't see why we need the word 'slut' at all. The word is dismissive and derisory. Promiscuous is a much better word - it doesn't judge and is easier to quantify. It is still relative and open to interpretation but it leaves the motivations of the promiscuous person unquestioned.
So - getting back to the OP - no, hotmilf, you aren't a slut because I don't believe in sluts, they don't exist. You aren't promiscuous either - not by modern standards. Having said all that, I am kind of left wondering why you care how other people might define you?
*I'm not questioning your motivation there, milf, I'm just looking at the question (hopefully) objectively - I hope you don't find this offensive - that certainly is not my intent.