As a gay guy, I can only speak for myself. But yes, for me a huge dick is more attractive than a muscled, ripped body, and a little more attractive than a handsome face.
When hooking up, definitely is my top standard, alongside masculinity. I’m really attracted sexually to masculine energy.
To be honest, when I’m really horny, I just want a big fat cock, I don’t care if the guy is ugly or not.
For dating, is a mixture of things, but definitely an above average cock is mandatory.
My thing with huge dicks, is how beautiful they are, I love to feel the girth on my hand, I love to put both of my hands a still have space for another hand or two, and I love the sensation of having my mouth and hole completely full of cock.