There is no answer to your question.
5x5 will be perfect for some women and too much / little of something or other for others.
We're not all the same - we like different things.
By the way: 5" is not short, it is average.
This is completely true. This site can lead one to believe that length and girth mean everything, and that the average is bigger than it actually is.
I'm not a woman who has ever sought out boyfriends based upon penis size and I've only ever had sex with one man whose penis was too small for me.
Penis size isn't everything. I've had sex with several men better endowed who were not all that great in the bedroom who couldn't hold a candle to men with better skills but less impressive dimensions.
Skill makes up for everything, or so I'm told
let's keep the the BS flowing...:tongue:
I have an 11" penis........AROUND!
In my opinion, girth can make up for almost anything. If you're cock is like a tuna can, then no... I need more length. But, in general, girth will always be more important to me than length.
Girth makes up for just about anything