have you ever been ask if a particular girl was tight?
Yes, no response though, that's between me and the woman, others experiences may vary.
have you ever asked another guy if a girl was tight?
No, never have, never will. I do what I need to do to find out for myself what the experience is about.
have you heard guys talking to each other about a girl being tight?
Yes, don't listen much to it though, other guy's talking about something I may or may never get the opportunity to experience.
have you ever told a girl she was tight?
Yes, meant only as a compliment, to me it's like telling her that she's fine, hot, phat.
For the record, even when something wasn't what I expected, the relationship didn't turn out for whatever reason, I don't sabotage reputations, and if I was the first, create a negative reputation or even recommendation. Someone asks me how something is, I recommend they do their own exploratory to find out where it goes. What does and doesn't work for me, may not exactly be good or bad for another in regards to a relationship. I'm not sure where you're going with the poll, but it sounds like you're interested in knowing about guy smack/talk. I will say I don't participate, but there is enough of it going on out there, that I don't have to, and whether any of it is even true is qualified by fact or fiction, the circumstances behind the comments and so on. I give every lady an oportunity that appeals to me and what I pursue. Another's comments don't weigh @ all in regards to the dating/mating game.