Originally posted by AlligatorJack@Dec 11 2004, 11:45 PM
From what I have read the term fag, as we know, is a bundle of sticks. Nazis used to tie up homosexuals and burn them, like firewood, they then started calling them "fags" ....
If you have read this, your sources are confused about dates. Faggots, or fagots, not fags, are bundles of sticks. Any dictionary will tell you that the use of fag or faggot came into use in print long before the Nazis, and was probably in spoken use even earlier. For example, Webster's 9th Collegiate puts the homosexaul use of faggot in print at 1914, and the same definition of fag in print at 1931. (Some other references will put the homosexual definition of fag at an earlier date then faggot). The Nazi party's rise to power was in the 1930's; Hitler took office in 1933. Therefore, the actions of the Nazis can hardly be responsible for coining a term that was in common, written use before they even existed.
An earlier post in this thread describes one commonly accepted origin of the homosexual meanings of fag and faggot. To summarize, in English boy's boarding schools, underclassmen were required to work as personal servants to upperclassmen. The word fag originally meant to frayed end of someting, or to become worn out from hard work, dating to about 1770. The younger boys that acted servants were called fags, because they were worked hard. This use of the word dates to about 1780. It is not too difficult to understand how a term for one young man in personal service to another man began to become a term to refer to men with a homosexual relationship. In this theory, fag comes first, and faggot later by association, perhaps aided by the Yidish faygele.
Some authorities give a different origin, which I do not believe. They say the homosexual meaning of fag is shortened from faggot, but then fail to give a plausible way that faggot came to mean homosexual, which is why I discount theory over the schoolboy one. For example, one of my dictionaries says "...homosexual as in awkward to carry, as in fagots (bundles of sticks) on the back." What they are getting at is that a man married to a bitch old woman has a wife that is awkward and unpleasant to carry. For a while such a nasty old woman was known as a faggot, and hence a homosexual man became known as a faggot. If this is true, I guess nasty queens and trolls have been with us for a long time! Somehow, I would like to belive that even a disparaging term for being gay came from the activeities of virile young men, rather than bitchy old queeens, and put my faith in the schoolboy theory above.