Had a girl that that tore pretty bad. We were young (legal age), she had limited experience and was super tight, lots of spit, lot of attempted entry then rubbing the head through her puffy lips, try again. Got in and she was really squirming/ struggling. With only a couple inches in I asked if I should pull it back out, she said no I just think you to big for me, just go slow. Got a rhythm going using a few inches, so tight! Then after a few minutes she was really wet and "open up" like crazy. I started getting some full strokes, her saying it hurt, me asking if she wanted to stop, her saying hell no. You sure? No, go ahead, I want to do this. I fucked her brains out. I creampied her, in missionary, after there was pink jizzum stains on the sheets. I freaked, thought she was a virgin, she assured me she was not a virgin but the couple guys before were not thick like me. She said your to thick, I think you split me in half. Next day, she's not in classes. I call her after school (no cell phones), she was home, sore and burning. She wanted me to come over after a couple days, Same scenario, super tight for a few minutes, then open up to what I would almost call a loose pussy. I was fascinated and the looser she got the harder I fucked her. It went this way every time the dozen times I fucked her. Never had doctor confirmation of a tear, but I assume that was what was happening