Wow, this thread sure went to talking about a Jamaican resort to an over analyzed philosophical discussion fast.
When I first heard about the resort I decided to read up on it and here is what I found:
The resort itself is split into two sides, a nude side and a "vanilla" side. The Vanilla side was more run down, had less activities, and was basically ignored by the staff. Meanwhile on the nude side, you obviously couldn't go there with clothes on, so no voyeurism, as it were, without participating.
There were some complaints about the place and staff I read from reviews. One was that male employees, like bellhops especially, would essentially start groping and trying to fuck the single girls/girlfriends/wives if they ended up in a room alone with them delivering food, luggage or what have you.
Another complaint was that there was a surprising number of single guys there trying to fuck other guys' wives without having brought anything to the banquet to share (though some couples who ere into that sort of thing posted this as a plus too, heh).
With regard to the ugly factor of some people there (which would completely turn me off at a nudist resort), apparently there is a website that I saw where couples going there can post pictures of themselves and arrange to go at the same time as other attractive people, and there is like a community of sorts based on that. Personally, not to be elitist or superficial, but I think there is a certain level of hotness people should have to have to even be allowed to go to the resort.
While I think it would be interesting to go, the closest my wife and I have ever come to that was going to the European topless pool all week at our hotel in Vegas on our honeymoon. That alone was tons of fun, and surprisingly enough it was mostly younger, attractive people there. Even though it wasn't a "Swinger" atmosphere (which is good since we aren't swingers), my wife still got a lot of attention, especially from one group of guys who was there for one guy's birthday, lol, though it was still a very relaxing and enjoyable time.
I'm not sure the hedonism trip would be nearly as relaxing though, being fully nude like that with a bunch of other people around, and my wife is gorgeous so I know she's be like a prime target for the staff guys, single guys and everyone else to try and fuck. Plus, in all modesty, we're both rather good looking and a very attractive couple (even if I'm not quite as well endowed as the majority of the guys on here, heh), so even together chances are we'd be getting propositioned alot, and I'd like to spent at least a good deal of our time there just relaxing and hanging out, not necessarily participating in the sexual meat market display and auction the entire time.