Hey guys - I couldn't find any threads on this. Lots on MMF, but few on MFF. Going in to this thing I found anecdotal experience really helpful in deciding to go ahead with it, so thought I'd start a thread on sharing our first MFF experience for any other lucky guys (or girls) out there considering it. Yes, it's a long story!
My girl and I are in our mid 20s; the other girl was an off-beat goth from one of her college classes who'd professed to my g/f a few times that she'd recently discovered the joys of hedonism. Recruiting her was very easy so we didn't have the same unicorn hunting issues a lot of people do. Both girls are exactly my type physically - very slim and very petite; 5'4" and 5'0" respectively.
We sort of got together under the impetus that we'd watch a movie at my place. We did, and I don't think any of us knew what to do. We lay on the bed together to watch the movie, I'd kiss my g/f from time to time and her friend spent a lot of time tickling her but it rarely seemed "erotic". After maybe an hour of this, the other girl and I caught each other's glances and both started kissing up my g/f.
My g/f giggled at first but quickly got settled in before the action started as we both kissed up and down her neck, taking turns to french her while the other sucked on her ear. We each grinded in to her for a bit -- then it was the other girl's turn. After watching the two girls kiss quite a lot I begun to feel the hints of threesome "jealousy" pangs I'd heard so much about, when one feels like the observer. I made out with the other girl for a bit but she quickly switched attention back to my g/f, who we continued to undress. My girl gave me her fair share of attention, but I was a little annoyed that the new girl wasn't that in to me.
As a sidenote, I had to try and hide my amazement at the new girl's perfect set of breasts. My girl's barely an A-cup, but this girl - in spite of being 5'0" - had what must've been a perfectly rounded pair of C-cups. Don't get me wrong - I'm an ass-man, and my g/f has the best hip-to-waist ratio of any girl I've ever been with, but this was a pleasantly surprising pair on such a tiny girl. My g/f later expressed a bit of "boob envy".
Anyway, eventually the two girls got naked and the other girl started going down on my g/f. This is when the second alarm started going off. I wasn't getting hard. Not even close. To obscure my disappointing flacid cock, I got behind the other girl and started going down on her, eating her out while she ate out my g/f. I played with my dick in a vain attempt to get hard, but nothing seemed to be working!!
Then things got a bit better. The other girl's whelping turned in to groaning, then in to moaning. Eventually she pulled back off my g/f and started saying in-between gasps of breath "sorry... I have to stop", then she knelt above me, straddling my face, giving me the perfect view of her perfect tits. I upped the intensity and she started to buckle, and at one point said "oh fuck, fuck he's so good at this, oh my god." After what felt like barely two minutes, she came as she fell forward on to the bed.
Things got even better from there. She turned around to see my hard cock and was suddenly very in to me, at which point the threesome became a lot more egalitarian. We daisy-chained, with the other girl showing me her new-found love for my cock while I went down on my g/f. After my g/f came, they both turned attention on to sucking my cock. This part went for a good half an hour and i loved every minute.
At that point, both girls agreed it was time for fucking... and things started to go downhill again. I put on a condom on. Condoms always, always make me go soft, especially since I was wearing a cock ring. I started to go soft inside my g/f so I eventually caved and took off the condom, and started fucking her while the other girl licked my balls and my g/f's clit. Yet -- I still couldn't get hard! Then things just got worse; in spite of being soft, I managed to come inside my g/f after probably only 3-4 minutes of unprotected fucking.
Neither girl knew what to do, but I reassured them I'd get hard and encouraged them to play with each other. The other girl reached in to her bag and pulled out a strapon and lubed up. She kept commenting on how it'd be too big for my g/f, who found it rather intimidating! I played with myself and - much to my surprise - managed to get hard again after only a few minutes.
At this point I stood up and asked the other girl to compare cocks. She broke in to a sweat looking at my cock dwarfing her strapon (well - actually it was a bit shorter, but a lot thicker). At this point she really wanted to ride me, but I'd used my only condom... so I had to fumble for an old box of regulars, which then promptly made me go soft again. Somehow this girl managed to ride me with a semi for a good few minutes, but I eventually had to ask her to stop. At this point we all just flopped on the bed - some an hour and a half after we'd first got naked - and basically got our breath back!
TL;DR - Bit of jealousy, but my excellent oral got me some attention. Amazing three-way oral followed by an embarassing early ejaculation experience, but quickly got hard again and managed to pleasure both girls. Everyone came.
---
Honestly; if I'd known I'd go soft twice and come early, I'd probably have expected it to be a bad night... but it was actually pretty good all things considered. The oral between the three of us was undeniably the best I've ever had, and I still got the cock worship that I crave so much. The other girl actually commented that she's currently seeing a guy with a bigger cock, but preferred the size of mine -- in fact she complained on the way home that even my soft cock was hitting her cervix! It's nice to know that while my cock isn't truly massive, it's a size that, in my experience, the kind of petite women I like seem to consider ideal.
While there was no jealousy between my g/f and I afterward, I must say it's a testament to her remarkable emotional maturity. She was really excited to watch me fuck her friend, and felt no shame that I liked playing with the other girl's breasts and made her come first. Similarly, I was fine with watching my g/f fucked with a strapon and being the recipient of a lot of attention. Admittedly, I'm worried that next time we have sex it might be uncomfortable.
As for next time, I think I won't have a problem getting hard as I won't feel jealous. I'll also have to try and find some "thin" large condoms, as the regular ones are major erection killers.
Anyway -- wanted to get that out there! Feel free to share your experiences, internet!
My girl and I are in our mid 20s; the other girl was an off-beat goth from one of her college classes who'd professed to my g/f a few times that she'd recently discovered the joys of hedonism. Recruiting her was very easy so we didn't have the same unicorn hunting issues a lot of people do. Both girls are exactly my type physically - very slim and very petite; 5'4" and 5'0" respectively.
We sort of got together under the impetus that we'd watch a movie at my place. We did, and I don't think any of us knew what to do. We lay on the bed together to watch the movie, I'd kiss my g/f from time to time and her friend spent a lot of time tickling her but it rarely seemed "erotic". After maybe an hour of this, the other girl and I caught each other's glances and both started kissing up my g/f.
My g/f giggled at first but quickly got settled in before the action started as we both kissed up and down her neck, taking turns to french her while the other sucked on her ear. We each grinded in to her for a bit -- then it was the other girl's turn. After watching the two girls kiss quite a lot I begun to feel the hints of threesome "jealousy" pangs I'd heard so much about, when one feels like the observer. I made out with the other girl for a bit but she quickly switched attention back to my g/f, who we continued to undress. My girl gave me her fair share of attention, but I was a little annoyed that the new girl wasn't that in to me.
As a sidenote, I had to try and hide my amazement at the new girl's perfect set of breasts. My girl's barely an A-cup, but this girl - in spite of being 5'0" - had what must've been a perfectly rounded pair of C-cups. Don't get me wrong - I'm an ass-man, and my g/f has the best hip-to-waist ratio of any girl I've ever been with, but this was a pleasantly surprising pair on such a tiny girl. My g/f later expressed a bit of "boob envy".
Anyway, eventually the two girls got naked and the other girl started going down on my g/f. This is when the second alarm started going off. I wasn't getting hard. Not even close. To obscure my disappointing flacid cock, I got behind the other girl and started going down on her, eating her out while she ate out my g/f. I played with my dick in a vain attempt to get hard, but nothing seemed to be working!!
Then things got a bit better. The other girl's whelping turned in to groaning, then in to moaning. Eventually she pulled back off my g/f and started saying in-between gasps of breath "sorry... I have to stop", then she knelt above me, straddling my face, giving me the perfect view of her perfect tits. I upped the intensity and she started to buckle, and at one point said "oh fuck, fuck he's so good at this, oh my god." After what felt like barely two minutes, she came as she fell forward on to the bed.
Things got even better from there. She turned around to see my hard cock and was suddenly very in to me, at which point the threesome became a lot more egalitarian. We daisy-chained, with the other girl showing me her new-found love for my cock while I went down on my g/f. After my g/f came, they both turned attention on to sucking my cock. This part went for a good half an hour and i loved every minute.
At that point, both girls agreed it was time for fucking... and things started to go downhill again. I put on a condom on. Condoms always, always make me go soft, especially since I was wearing a cock ring. I started to go soft inside my g/f so I eventually caved and took off the condom, and started fucking her while the other girl licked my balls and my g/f's clit. Yet -- I still couldn't get hard! Then things just got worse; in spite of being soft, I managed to come inside my g/f after probably only 3-4 minutes of unprotected fucking.
Neither girl knew what to do, but I reassured them I'd get hard and encouraged them to play with each other. The other girl reached in to her bag and pulled out a strapon and lubed up. She kept commenting on how it'd be too big for my g/f, who found it rather intimidating! I played with myself and - much to my surprise - managed to get hard again after only a few minutes.
At this point I stood up and asked the other girl to compare cocks. She broke in to a sweat looking at my cock dwarfing her strapon (well - actually it was a bit shorter, but a lot thicker). At this point she really wanted to ride me, but I'd used my only condom... so I had to fumble for an old box of regulars, which then promptly made me go soft again. Somehow this girl managed to ride me with a semi for a good few minutes, but I eventually had to ask her to stop. At this point we all just flopped on the bed - some an hour and a half after we'd first got naked - and basically got our breath back!
TL;DR - Bit of jealousy, but my excellent oral got me some attention. Amazing three-way oral followed by an embarassing early ejaculation experience, but quickly got hard again and managed to pleasure both girls. Everyone came.
---
Honestly; if I'd known I'd go soft twice and come early, I'd probably have expected it to be a bad night... but it was actually pretty good all things considered. The oral between the three of us was undeniably the best I've ever had, and I still got the cock worship that I crave so much. The other girl actually commented that she's currently seeing a guy with a bigger cock, but preferred the size of mine -- in fact she complained on the way home that even my soft cock was hitting her cervix! It's nice to know that while my cock isn't truly massive, it's a size that, in my experience, the kind of petite women I like seem to consider ideal.
While there was no jealousy between my g/f and I afterward, I must say it's a testament to her remarkable emotional maturity. She was really excited to watch me fuck her friend, and felt no shame that I liked playing with the other girl's breasts and made her come first. Similarly, I was fine with watching my g/f fucked with a strapon and being the recipient of a lot of attention. Admittedly, I'm worried that next time we have sex it might be uncomfortable.
As for next time, I think I won't have a problem getting hard as I won't feel jealous. I'll also have to try and find some "thin" large condoms, as the regular ones are major erection killers.
Anyway -- wanted to get that out there! Feel free to share your experiences, internet!