I strongly believe that most guys, however straight they appear, are interested or at least ok with being with another guy. There's some stat that 1 in 5 guys are openly gay and 60% of all males have experienced a M2M sexual encounter between the ages of 18 and 40.
Are you sure this is a statistic and not just hopeful fantasy? Maybe this is close to true for the men on this site, but I think the guys here are a very skewed sample of society in general, being that it's a site for people into big cocks.
I'm open to being attracted to men or women, though find that on a sexual level, men catch my interest more quickly and more often. There have been quite a few guys in the past few years I've met as friends and have found myself attracted to. After getting to know them, they have all, yes all, turned out to be only attracted to women. They are all aware that I'm fluid sexually, and I've had very open discussions about this with all of them at one point or another. When I ask them if they've ever been attracted to a guy or have ever done anything with a guy, however, they have
all answered no and that they have absolutely zero interest. With this experience, it is hard for me to believe the idea that "nobody is 100% straight" or that most guys have some kind of secret fantasy about being with other men. As a guy who seem to be attracted only to heterosexual men, I'd LOVE it if the majority of heterosexual guys bent this way a bit now and then, but from my experience, they don't.
As to your situation, though, I think you're definitely on the right site to be able to meet some men who are in the same boat as you. It sounds like you could really use somebody to talk to. Are the two guys you're physical with not good candidates for this?