I'm not sure how a tight hole could be overrated, buck.
I prefer open, relaxed sloppy hole. I actually find tight hole to be unwelcoming. Of course, I'm willing to invest the time and energy required to get it that way before I fuck it.
I do not clearly understand what you are saying. Are you saying you prefer small, unirc'd cocks or that you simply don't notice unless they are small and uncut?
Just in case you didn't know, I'm a strict non-versatile top.
I'm saying that if I know that someone's got a big cut cock, I avoid them even if they fit all my other criteria. I'm also saying that I really have no interest anymore in putting a cock in my mouth unless it's small(ish) and uncut. That's just me, and I know that it makes me very much in the minority here.
But I did not join LPSG because I like big dicks, I joined because I've got one.
Also, I would add big pecs to your list of over-rated virtues. Give me an "average" guy anytime so I don't have to compete with the gym and/or all the bunnies therein.
I gotta agree with you. I like a guy be to be in shape, but gym bunnies are almost always too vain to attract much attention. I find humility very attractive.