Interesting topic, great thread.
My last boyfriend had just under 9 inches and was pretty think too.
He was the greatest sex I ever had. He used to take it really slow in
the beginning so I'd get used to him. Once I'd really relax, then he'd let me really have it. I could take the whole thing. He'd tell me how much he loved going so deep in me. Funny thing is too, we could go for really long sessions before we'd cum. I never hurt the next day and my ass always remained tight.
On the other hand, I've been fucked by much smaller coccks and my ass hurt the next day. Go figure.
BTW if you're wondering why I'm not with the "big guy" anymore. Well, he died.
Don't feel bad tho, I have a great memory.
billy