I have never thought much about it but I would put myself at definitely "above average" and being the spitting image of my father (who at 55 is a very handsome man indeed) I think if I can look as good as HIM when I am that age - I will be okay! I never lacked for dates or sex when I was a lad (admittedly that has got to be partly due to my cock) so i do have confidence - and confidence can make one look very attractive.
I guess what really says it is a tee shirt my wife gave me for Christmas last year: a light blue nylon tee shirt with black lettering that says "I Would Fuck Me."
Tony