I measure between 5.5 and 6 inches thick - depending on how close I am to bursting. And every woman I've been with who has commented (most of them) have said I feel very big inside them. I've also had a lot of compliments on cam sites - some may not be genuine but I think many are.
This has been my exact same experience and we are very similar.
I start out at about 5.6 towards my head and finish around 6.1 at the very base. I am around 7 inches long on the average day. When super turned on I max at 7.4
all the women I have been with have been very surprised after they get it in them. I think girth tends to take women by surprise in general compared to length instantly making them think it’s big.
Several of the women I have been with were very sexually experienced and they always placed me at the top or near the very top as far as size wise and how I felt in them. Comments like “you fill me up, it feels thick” and then them wanting pictures after sex. Some of them were expecting to have to adjust to the size and the stretching to the point where they would ask me to slow down and I would need to give them more time and this was even after foreplay.
girth adds a ton of volume. A 7 inch long dick with 6 inches of girth actually feels bigger to a woman than an 8 1/2 inch long dick with 5.25 inches of girth in most cases. It just takes up more space/ mass.
Like many guys there are times where I have wished I had even an inch longer in length but the truth of the matter is girth gives women that feeling of fullness that they often times crave and I wouldn’t want to trade that!