titan1968
Loved Member
- Joined
- Jul 7, 2004
- Posts
- 876
- Media
- 5
- Likes
- 748
- Points
- 313
- Location
- Montreal (Quebec, Canada)
- Sexuality
- 50% Straight, 50% Gay
- Gender
- Male
No Gillette, I am not suggesting that Queen Isabella was able to foresee every action, I am suggesting that she knew what the outcome would be. The Non-Catholics had been deemed a threat to the Roman Catholic Church and the Spanish Crown, and that threat had to be removed , hence the Spanish Inquisition. The goals of the Inquisition were the consolidation of power of the Church and the power of the Crown.
However, Columbus was made viceroy (i.e. governor) of all the lands he 'discovered'. In other words, all the lands he discovered-- inhabited or not, became property of the Spanish Crown. Yes, they all did it.
My point is that greed-- the strong and selfish desire for power and wealth, is not limited to one sex, and no matter how hard one tries to rationalise it, greed is still greed.
.[/quote]
2. Right. First off, the only indigenous peoples they expected to find were Asians since Columbus' voyage was intended to find an alternate route to the silk road. The initial purpose was trade not conquer. Second, please keep in mind her greed was for the purpose of strengthening her country, the people for whom she was directly responsible. Can you show me a single ruler of the time who gave a rat's ass about indigenous people when there was land to be had. I still contend the only thing that makes her stick out is the fact she was a woman.[/quote]
1. Yes she gave her blessing. By some accounts some two years after the papal bull was made available to her, after being given reports, confirmed by Torquemada, that "conversos", those jews or muslims who had converted to christianity but who were believed to still be practicing their original faith, were actively weakening catholic political aims. As presented and authorized the inquisition only had authority with regard to the conversos and had none over those practicing their original faith. What you are suggesting is that Isabella was able to forsee every action that every inquisitor would ever make once it was begun. That's preposterous.
.
However, Columbus was made viceroy (i.e. governor) of all the lands he 'discovered'. In other words, all the lands he discovered-- inhabited or not, became property of the Spanish Crown. Yes, they all did it.
My point is that greed-- the strong and selfish desire for power and wealth, is not limited to one sex, and no matter how hard one tries to rationalise it, greed is still greed.
.[/quote]
2. Right. First off, the only indigenous peoples they expected to find were Asians since Columbus' voyage was intended to find an alternate route to the silk road. The initial purpose was trade not conquer. Second, please keep in mind her greed was for the purpose of strengthening her country, the people for whom she was directly responsible. Can you show me a single ruler of the time who gave a rat's ass about indigenous people when there was land to be had. I still contend the only thing that makes her stick out is the fact she was a woman.[/quote]