Well, as in so many Hollywood histories, Hunter is far more the stud on camera than off. Meaning... in person I have seen him act very immaturely; even gigglely and perhaps almost nelly.
He may pray to Hay-Soos on the outside, but methinks he'd be happy sucking a cigar "of sort" otherwise.....
Just my "radar"
I could be wrong.
Usually I'm not.
This is GREAT news, and explains why someone thought him an ultra-conservative religious freak. Agents in Hollywood still think it's 1945 and that they need to quickly cover for any of their young clients possible future gayness so they intentionally play up anything that they think might contradict that in the public's eye. Even if in 2008, the contradictions really just hurt the star and his or her actual image, by after a while just seeming too contradictory and confusing to a great number of their possible fan base.
(Many of these young stars eventually end up with very serious drug and alcohol issues from the stress of thinking they have to live so many lies, several have even died young from it. Some dieing with their 'unnecessary-in-2008 secrets' in tact to most of the public. Truly simultaneously quite tragic and silly.)
Lance Bass of 'N Sync was once said to be very very religious and traditional etc. too by Hollywood publicists. This was meant as code for "despite what you may hear, he's not gay." Now he has come out of the closet as gay indeed. There are many stories like this.
Anyway, gay, bi, bi-curious or whatever, if he's doing Spring Awakening, he's trying to tell us that he is trying to break free of his controlling Hollywood agents/family's control and show he is NOT REALLY an ultra-conservative, that's for sure.