What would you guys consider the ideal penis size? For me, I would say a solid 8 or 9 inches with moderate thickness. I've been with guys bigger than that, and, while nice to look at, it's harder to do anything with a dick that big. I'm currently 7.5 inches when hard, so if I was about an inch longer and just a little thicker I'd be perfectly happy with that. No one has ever complained about my current size, but I think it'd look better just a little bit bigger.