If you had to pick...

[woodyq]

between 2 bottoms:
bottom 1 is an anal virgin and may not be able to take it deep or rough but is probably tight as can be and you would probably see him struggle a bit
or
bottom 2 been around the block can take it deep, can take a pounding but its another day at the office like no big deal not much reaction

which one would you fuck

 

[notN2pussy]

Wow, tough one!

 

[595965]

I'd take bottom 1. It's always quite satisfying for both parties when it has all gone as planned.

 

[elklindoxxx]

I've had both #1 and #2.

Sex was more pleasurable with #1. Gradually working in my bone and loosening him up until I can gently thrust with a good pace to cumshot. Nice tight and just right!!!

 

[Badunkbadonk]

I am desperately seeking #2. Guys say they want a thick cock, but they are usually too tight to handle my extreme 7"+ girth. Plus my dick is pretty short, like 5 inches. Makes it nigh on impossible to fuck a guy, so I usually bottom.

 

[Brodie888]

You'd probably take the tight one so you can custom fit his hole to your penis.

Nobody wants anus that hang like wizard's sleeve lol

 

[bravesoldier]

Probably the experienced guy. I say that from my own anal virgin experience. First time I tried it wouldn't go in at all. Never quite figured that out because I'd had toys in my ass before. He and I tried several times, I think it might have been the angle of his cock. Finally it went in and hurt worse than anything I ever imagined.

 

[KennF]

I'd take whichever one I liked more. However, all other things being exactly equal, I would prefer the first guy who wanted it and was willing to trust me. The second sounds bored and not into it... I don't want to be 'another day at the office', I want to feel special.