Is Johnny Sins the Greatest Male Pornstar of All Time?

Is Johnny the GOAT?

  • Yes

    Votes: 250 39.7%
  • No, it's Manuel Ferrara

    Votes: 210 33.3%
  • No, It's someone else

    Votes: 170 27.0%

  • Total voters
    630

ASexMrHung1

Loved Member
Account Deletion Pending
Joined
Jan 13, 2017
Posts
319
Media
0
Likes
590
Points
313
Location
Los Angeles (California, United States)
Sexuality
90% Straight, 10% Gay
Gender
Male
Try to avoid bias with your vote, everyone has personal preference but I'm talking strictly as a performer and what he's meant to the porn industry..

I was watching an early scene from Brazzers with Johnny Sins and Devon Michaels and it got me thinking that he is probably the GOAT.

The reason I made this poll..the amount of hate that other pornstars have gotten as they've aged..For some reason I rarely see people posting about Johnny Sins being a bad performer, sure I've seen him get blamed for overexposure but I've never seen people trash him as a performer. I've seen almost every other modern pornstar get called 'past his prime' or 'looking old' or 'washed up' Keiran Lee is one, he's been getting a lot of hate as he's aged. Is it because Johnny Sins was already bald and has looked relatively the same since he joined the industry?

1. Costars frequently list him as one of their favorite stars to shoot with. (others are Manuel Ferrara and James Deen before he got into trouble)

2. Longevity & Consistency- Sins started on the wrong side of his 20s and he's in his 40s now and very rarely has he not given a quality performance even in his 40s. I would want someone to show me a scene where he was struggling There was a window where the best pornstars were working every single day and sometimes multiple shoots per day..with the development of video and then internet porn making it so easy to create content, and onlyfans not being a thing for another decade. Peter North has to be up there..Erik Everhard..Lex Steele..and Manuel as well with him winning so many Performer of the Year awards..

3. People who don't watch porn (or don't admit they watch it) recognize him and he has popularity outside of porn due to his fitness regime and memes.

4. He has always taken such good care of his body and treats himself like a professional athlete..Manuel and some of the others have gotten thicker as they've aged and life has caught up to them (kids, wife, commitments, etc.)..There was only a brief period where Sins was away and he came back looking the same.


Jut curious what others thinks, he really has been top notch over the years and eventually his time will come and he will fade away into retirement and others will take his place but it would be difficult to find another male performer who has been more successful in the industry..The only other one I think is in the running is Manuel Ferrara.
 

ASexMrHung1

Loved Member
Account Deletion Pending
Joined
Jan 13, 2017
Posts
319
Media
0
Likes
590
Points
313
Location
Los Angeles (California, United States)
Sexuality
90% Straight, 10% Gay
Gender
Male
Love Johnny, but not as good as Lex Steele, Rocco SIffredi, Peter North, Mark Ashley or JMac

All of those guys are in the running. I get the appeal of Rocco Siffredi but sometimes I wonder why people are so obsessed with his work. Violent anal action doesn't make a good scene and that is his speciality
 
  • Like
Reactions: lapdog2001

bimaarya

Worshipped Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2018
Posts
1,188
Media
0
Likes
13,362
Points
308
Location
Bandung, Bandung City, West Java, Indonesia
Sexuality
Non-Binary
Gender
Male
for me- I find his porn very vanilla. Nothing wrong with that. He has vanilla vibes too doesnt catch my attention at all. Every single scene is the same doesnt matter the year, the girl, or the porn scene. Tried and true though i guess for his fans.

If you judging by his 1000 scenes from Brazzers, Naughty America, Reality Kings, MrBigDickHotChicks etc yeah you're right. All his scene are typical, scrpited & choreographed but if you check hi OF page he doing so many thing. Very raw, unfiltered, rough, hard just pure sex. He fucked all womens in every size & colors.. He's not only Vanilla. He's a chocolate, latte, americano oreo lol


vlcsnap-2021-12-12-23h42m48s524.png
vlcsnap-2021-05-19-01h20m14s705.png
vlcsnap-2021-03-21-17h24m40s094.png
vlcsnap-2021-05-11-02h19m56s360.png
vlcsnap-2021-02-23-01h07m25s824.png
vlcsnap-2021-03-21-02h50m56s114.png
vlcsnap-2021-06-03-02h28m23s791.png
vlcsnap-2021-11-21-03h08m19s614.png
vlcsnap-2021-05-16-01h39m24s472.png
vlcsnap-2021-04-30-10h25m31s883.png
 

blueballsinasuit

Legendary Member
Verified
Gold
Joined
Jan 5, 2010
Posts
421
Media
21
Likes
1,110
Points
373
Location
St. Charles (Illinois, United States)
Verification
View
Sexuality
80% Straight, 20% Gay
Gender
Male
He's boring, IMO. And I don't think he's ever done a MFM scene, which to me is the ultimate threshold by which straight performers earn my praise.

Bill Bailey (RIP) was my favorite for many years.
 

ASexMrHung1

Loved Member
Account Deletion Pending
Joined
Jan 13, 2017
Posts
319
Media
0
Likes
590
Points
313
Location
Los Angeles (California, United States)
Sexuality
90% Straight, 10% Gay
Gender
Male
H
He's boring, IMO. And I don't think he's ever done a MFM scene, which to me is the ultimate threshold by which straight performers earn my praise.

Bill Bailey (RIP) was my favorite for many years.
I've never seen him do DP but he's done MFM with Scott Nails and Keiran Lee . He doesn't seem to have much interest in men though, so he only performs with women.
 

longstroke7

Mythical Member
Joined
Nov 7, 2011
Posts
11,553
Media
0
Likes
28,072
Points
318
Sexuality
100% Straight, 0% Gay
Gender
Male
Sins is definitely one of the best of all time hands down.


The dude has to be pushing 20+ years in the game and he's still out there doing great content shoots. Never seen him struggle with any performer, his dick stays rock hard and he fucks the shit out of his partners. This guy was out there laying some punishing fucks into names like Jenna Haze, Jayden Jaymes, you name it and he's still active.
 
3

3790721

Guest
Johnny Sins does absolutely nothing for me, he's like invinsible to me. When I see him on a video it's an automatic clic next.

I can't name a single greatest male porn star as there are many I love but Johnny SIns is definitely at the very bottom of my list.
 

Bloodbender63

Experimental Member
Joined
Dec 15, 2021
Posts
14
Media
0
Likes
22
Points
3
Location
Cabuyao, Calabarzon,Philippines
Sexuality
100% Gay, 0% Straight
Johnny Sins does absolutely nothing for me, he's like invinsible to me. When I see him on a video it's an automatic clic next.

I can't name a single greatest male porn star as there are many I love but Johnny SIns is definitely at the very bottom of my list.
I agree with you. He's overrated. Johnny Castle is even hotter.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3790721