I would agree with the majority of posters above, that yes there is such a thing as too muscular. What I find much more important than muscle size, is defintion. I find a guy who is lean and defined, with a strong fit body, much more attractive than a guy with a overly muscular, thick, and undefined body. About the only area ona guy where he can not be too muscular is the abdominal area. A great, ripped, tight six-pack is always a great thing. But beyond that, there is a point where a guy is just too muscular. I also believe (being on the short side myself) that there is a point where a guy is too tall, but that is another issue for another post someday.