I am just barely above average in girth -- about 6 but working towards 6.5 and above with jelqs and way above average in length, 10. Judging by comments from dozens of guys who have watched me jack on cam, I have a near perfect penis, comments all being about the same. I did ask some of the gay onlookers what they would change if anything and only one said, "maybe 0.75 or inch in girth". But these were lookers not fuck or suck partners so cannot say what a more active participant might think.