[quote author=mindseye link=board=meetgreet;num=1075825894;start=0#12 date=02/03/04 at 18:04:04]Equally important, they were disrespectful to the players and coaches of Sunday's game. These players practiced hard; the coaches did their homework; and together they put on one of the best Superbowl games in recent memory. Jackson and Timberlake upstaged them and robbed them of much of the attention they deserved.
I've been a fan of Janet's work -- especially Rhythm Nation 1814 and The Velvet Rope. I can't imagine I'll be supportive of her newest album.[/quote]
Okay, here's my take. I think you make good points overall, but I politely disagree with the resulting consequence of your judgment.
The fact is, MTV produced the halftime show, and as soon as I saw the roster of acts, quite honestly, it was damned from the start. I'm not a particular fan of any of those artists, save Janet, and when they started doing familiar numbers, it made me that much more disinterested. Janet didn't do anything original, save the tit incident, but I was always a great fan of her choreography and stage presence. Could she have sang her song instead of lip-synch to it? Sure... but hey...
New England and Carolina came with their A-game and though I was disappointed that a field goal made all the difference, it was a good game, no question. They kept each other on their toes and Carolina kept coming back strong. If either team slacked at any moment until the last quarter, the game wouldn't have been nearly as intense. That's the kind of football that would make me a fan, had I given a damn about the sport in general...
To say that Janet and Justin had upstaged the entire game would be taking things a bit too damn far, really. As I recall, the fans of either team were cheering, yelling, and carousing just as loudly and wildly before the show as they did after. The performance was... provocative... and yes, it bordered on titillating (no pun intended), but the game continued unerred. I highly doubt that one tit really upset the balance of the game that much...
...and if we are to make such accusations, let's just take a look at that streaker fellow.
Janet bared her tit, but Justin was the one to swipe the covering off of her braziere. It was Justin's routine playing and the tit was Justin's finale. Janet agreed to the stunt. The stunt was in questionable taste, and though I'm unsure just how much of the audience consisted of younger viewers, I remember hearing screams of excitement -- not boos, jeers, guffaws, or torches being ignited in fury and condemnation. Hell, I was screaming like a damn fool in sexual excitement, too.
But are we to make heavy-handed judgments? What I mean is, how degenerate of a nation can we possibly be to emphasize this incident, knowing good and damn well that our everyday programming is riddled with violence, gender politics, drugs, harsh depictions, and plenty of gratuity boobie? Sure, MTV's played heavily into that titillation angle to satisfy its younger demographic, but come now, we've seen it before and we've seen it plenty. If this were Victorian England, oh God yes, we shalt scream and fuss! But wake up. It's 2004 and it hardly qualifies as a travesty.
It was a move in poor taste provided by MTV, "television programming" of the youth, and it was for show. It was a promotional stunt, or maybe some risqué since Janet really hasn't done that much in the way of the sensual in quite a long time. But, seriously, lighten up. Like I said, we see way worse on a day-to-day basis...
Never mind, I'm still tempted to wonder why this one little stunt makes Janet deemed an unworthy artist. Okay, so if Britney's bordering on naked in her latest video, it wouldn't matter because she's a heavily manufactured artist devoid of personal strength and integrity in her "songs." Her whole stage presence is a show, softcore porn. And L'il Kim... yeah... she originated the booby pasty (re: MTV Music Awards, 2002, perhaps?), but her scandalousness was an expectation, too. She's done hoochie forever...
But Janet's no less a talented singer, songwriter, and dancer because of her show. So she indulged in a little fun that was questionably suitable; it was agreeable and consensual. And though Justin so didn't deserve to feel her up, hey... no big deal.
Ease down.