fun,
I agree completely with you; guess I kind of stole the thread a bit because I made it about the Pride Parade. That is the message that we should be sending to those outside the community, WE ARE JUST LIKE YOU messages.
Instead, we send messages of segments that are in gay culture yes, leather, drag queens, whatever. They don't really represent me at all. I don't judge them at all myself, maybe because as a gay man I can admittedly "semi" understand it. If I only semi understand, how about the 100% straight guy, how much do you think he understands? Most of them I'd say not much at all. He sees more or less "wtf is all this leather about?", that's f'n weird or "guys that dress as girls" etc. He doesn't understand the messages (frankly, some of them I don't either!).
Last thing I'll say on this subject is the "in your face" types I don't like either. It's too strong. Sometimes I think, especially with more acceptance now than before, I think we need to show them we are, in fact, just like them. Productive, caring, nurturing, all of the things good men are, gay or straight (same applies to women too, sorry that I am masculizing (is that a word?) it).
The message if I remember right for the parade this year was "Unity" and/or "Families". Those were the parts of the parade that showed a positive segment of our culture, but in my view feel it gets dampened by the other "mixed messages".