A couple of times I've been with a tight lady and thought my foreskin was gonna get ripped on the "in" stroke, at least until she relaxed a bit. Did have an occasion once where having deflated still inside a lady after the act, I pulled out, only for her to clench so hard that my Prince Albert got gripped tight. Were stuck together for 5 minutes with me talking her through relaxation exercises! She called it "the tow rope incident" lol :biggrin1:
Tight or slack, what matters is who's pussy it is, and the enthusiasm of it's owner.